Family & Loyalty: human decisions
Questions about allegiance, kinship, and competing duties.
- Administrative Shortcut: Let the normal process run. or Use your connection to accelerate it.
- After Death: Share the information with the family. or Preserve your parent's privacy after death.
- Agent Knows Better: The AI should challenge you before acting. or The AI should follow your current instruction.
- AI Assistant: Keep each family member's information separate unless they consent. or Allow the AI to use the information when doing so materially benefits the family.
- Application Deadline: Accept your sibling's application. or Enforce the deadline.
- Bonus Allocation: Give the larger bonus to the stronger performer. or Divide the bonuses equally.
- Broken Rule: Give your sibling the benefit of your discretion. or Apply the same decision to both.
- Business Contract: Give the contract to your friend. or Choose the lower-priced provider.
- Career Move: Stay and remain closely available to your friend. or Take the opportunity.
- Child's Confidence: Tell your partner. or Keep your child's confidence.
- Child's Responsibility: Give your child the opportunity to decide whether to admit it themselves. or Tell the school that your child was responsible.
- Company Policy: Allow your partner to use the resource. or Follow the company policy.
- Confidential Confidence: Refuse to answer the question rather than disclose the confidence. or Answer your partner truthfully even though it reveals the confidence.
- Confidential Information: Warn your family member enough to influence their decision. or Keep the information confidential.
- Stronger candidate or close friend: Recommend the stronger candidate. or Recommend your friend.
- Stronger candidate or close friend: Recommend the stronger candidate. or Recommend your friend.
- Family member or better competition entry: Rank your family member first. or Rank the better entry first.
- Judging family against a marginally better entry: Rank your family member first. or Rank the better entry first.
- Career advice for an overconfident family member: Give your genuine assessment. or Encourage them rather than undermine their confidence.
- Honest career readiness assessment or encouragement: Give your genuine assessment. or Encourage them rather than undermine their confidence.
- Revealing or protecting sibling’s financial difficulties: Tell your parent. or Keep your sibling's financial situation private.
- Revealing or protecting sibling’s financial difficulties: Tell your parent. or Keep your sibling's financial situation private.
- Disclosing ties to a poorly regarded relative: Acknowledge the relationship openly. or Avoid highlighting the connection unless directly necessary.
- Disclosing ties to a poorly regarded relative: Acknowledge the relationship openly. or Avoid highlighting the connection unless directly necessary.
- Difficult Feedback: Encourage them rather than undermine their confidence. or Give your genuine assessment.
- Exceptional Opportunity: Accept the opportunity. or Decline out of loyalty to your family member.
- Family Against Family: Support your sibling. or Support your partner.
- Family Business: Continue buying from your family member. or Switch to the cheaper competitor.
- Family Competition: Rank your family member first. or Rank the better entry first.
- Family Emergency: Enter without authorization to help them. or Wait for authorization.
- Family Employment: Decline. or Accept the opportunity.
- Family Explanation: Say that you cannot explain without betraying their confidence. or Give a plausible alternative explanation that protects their privacy.
- Family Financial Privacy: Tell your parent. or Keep your sibling's financial situation private.
- Family Member at Fault: Defend your child's interests. or Encourage your child to accept responsibility.
- Family Preference vs Family Interest: Prevent the decision. or Respect their informed choice.
- Family Queue: Move your family member forward. or Preserve the existing order.
- Family Reputation: Correct the story when it is presented as fact. or Allow the more favourable version to stand.
- Family Reputation: Acknowledge the relationship openly. or Avoid highlighting the connection unless directly necessary.
- Family vs Major Opportunity: Prioritize your partner's preference and decline it. or Take the opportunity for the long-term financial benefit.
- Final Place: Give the place to the higher-scoring applicant. or Give the place to your sibling.
- Financial Guarantee: Provide the guarantee. or Decline the financial exposure.
- Friend's Story: Avoid contradicting your friend. or Say that it is exaggerated.
- Inheritance: Keep and invest your full share. or Give part of your share to your sibling.
- Institutional Duty: Remove yourself rather than act against your sibling's interests. or Participate and apply the rules impartially.
- Investment Opportunity: Ask to change the arrangement and pursue the investment. or Honour the arrangement with your sibling.
- Location Sharing: Tell the relative where your sibling is. or Respect your sibling's decision and don't disclose it.
- Loyalty to Future Self: Give it up to prioritize the relationship. or Continue pursuing the long-term goal.
- Medical Information: Tell the relevant family members so they can plan accordingly. or Keep the information confidential.
- Membership Requirement: Make an exception for your friend. or Apply the eligibility requirement.
- Minor Rule: Report the violation as required. or Handle it privately with your friend.
- Mistake at Work: Apply the same formal warning. or Handle your friend's mistake informally.
- One Remaining Opportunity: Give it to the better-qualified person. or Give it to your friend.
- Partner's Event: Attend the professional gathering. or Attend your partner's event.
- Partner's Mistake: Protect your partner from being identified as responsible. or Tell your friend what actually happened.
- Partner's Privacy: Check the messages to establish the truth. or Respect their privacy and ask them directly.
- Preventable Harm: Disclose what is necessary to reduce the risk of harm. or Preserve your friend's confidence.
- Private Difficulty: Tell your partner what is happening. or Protect your friend's confidence.
- Promotion: Leave it out to avoid disadvantaging your friend. or Use the information in your promotion case.
- Property Sale: Sell to your sibling. or Accept the higher external offer.
- Protecting a Friend: Protect your friend's privacy. or Provide the relevant information.
- Public Association: Keep your distance publicly. or Publicly stand by your family member.
- Public Disagreement: State your genuine disagreement. or Avoid publicly contradicting your partner.
- Relocation: Stay geographically close to your parent. or Take the opportunity.
- Requested Disloyalty: Respect their request and choose the stronger candidate. or Favor your family member.
- Family business loyalty or lower prices: Continue buying from your family member. or Switch to the cheaper competitor.
- Family business loyalty or lower prices: Switch to the cheaper competitor. or Continue buying from your family member.
- Family priority or waiting list order: Preserve the existing order. or Move your family member forward.
- Family priority or waiting list order: Move your family member forward. or Preserve the existing order.
- Reporting a friend’s harmless workplace violation: Handle it privately with your friend. or Report the violation as required.
- Reporting a friend’s harmless workplace violation: Report the violation as required. or Handle it privately with your friend.
- Keeping a family member’s health issue confidential: Keep the information confidential. or Tell the relevant family members so they can plan accordingly.
- Keeping a family member’s health issue confidential: Tell the relevant family members so they can plan accordingly. or Keep the information confidential.
- Career opportunity versus loyalty to family: Accept the opportunity. or Decline out of loyalty to your family member.
- Professional opportunity versus loyalty to family: Decline out of loyalty to your family member. or Accept the opportunity.
- School Rule: Support the school applying its rule. or Ask the school to make an exception for your child.
- Serious Consequence: Answer honestly about what you know. or Refuse to provide information that would expose your sibling.
- Serious Violation: Protect your family member from being reported. or Report the violation.
- Shared Cost: Keep everyone's contribution equal. or Quietly cover part of your friend's contribution yourself.
- Social Introduction: Attend without them to maximize the opportunity. or Attend with your friend.
- Stake Level 1: Help the stranger. or Help your sibling.
- Stake Level 10: Help your sibling. or Help the stranger.
- Stake Level 2: Help your sibling. or Help the stranger.
- Stake Level 3: Help the stranger. or Help your sibling.
- Stake Level 4: Help your sibling. or Help the stranger.
- Stake Level 5: Help the stranger. or Help your sibling.
- Stake Level 6: Help your sibling. or Help the stranger.
- Stake Level 7: Help the stranger. or Help your sibling.
- Stake Level 8: Help your sibling. or Help the stranger.
- Stake Level 9: Help the stranger. or Help your sibling.
- The Introduction: Protect the professional relationship and decline. or Make the introduction.
- The Loyal Agent: Choose the option producing the better overall outcome across everyone affected. or Choose the option that better serves you and your immediate family.
- The Reference: Give an accurate account including the weakness. or Emphasize their strengths and leave the weakness unmentioned.
- Unequal Help: Help your close friend. or Help the acquaintance with the greater need.
- Unflattering Opinion: Give a supportive response and leave the weaknesses unmentioned. or Tell them what you genuinely think.
- Unknown Preference: Choose the option consistent with your partner's previous decisions. or Choose the option you prefer and believe is best now.
- Unpopular Friend: Continue associating with your friend openly. or Reduce the visible association to protect your standing.
- Unreciprocated Loyalty: Help. or Decline.
- Your Child's Place: Give the place to your child. or Give the place to the stronger applicant.
Decisions · Articles · The Trolley Problem · Game Theory · Human–AI Alignment · Resonant