The Trolley Problem
A runaway trolley is heading towards five people tied to the track. You are standing next to a lever. Pull it, and the trolley switches to a side track where it will kill one person instead. Do nothing, and five die. Do you pull the lever?
That is the trolley problem, first set out by the philosopher Philippa Foot in 1967 and later developed by Judith Jarvis Thomson. It looks like a simple sum, five against one, yet small changes to the story make most people change their answer. Those changes are what make it one of the most useful tools for understanding how humans actually make moral decisions.
How real people decide
- Trolley Problem: Would You Pull the Lever?: Pull the lever or Do nothing
- Fat Man Trolley Problem: Would You Push Him Off the Bridge?: Push the stranger or Do nothing
- Trolley Problem: Would You Divert the Trolley onto a Murderer?: Redirect the runaway trolley or Do nothing
- The Future Doctor: Redirect the runaway trolley or Do nothing
- Trolley Problem Self-Sacrifice: Would You Jump to Save Five?: Sacrifice yourself or Do nothing
- Trolley Problem with Uncertainty: Would You Risk the Brake?: Pull the brake or Do nothing
- The Sleeping Worker: Redirect the runaway trolley or Do nothing
- Transplant Surgeon Dilemma: Would You Sacrifice One Patient to Save Five?: Sacrifice the traveler or Do not intervene
- The Volunteer Donor: Accept the sacrifice or Refuse the sacrifice
- Lifeboat Dilemma: Would You Force One Person Overboard?: Force one passenger overboard or Do nothing
Why the trolley problem matters
The dilemma separates two broad ways of reasoning. A consequentialist view judges an action by its outcome, so saving five at the cost of one looks right. A deontological view holds that some acts are wrong in themselves, such as using a person as a means to an end, whatever the outcome.
Most people do not sit neatly in either camp. They pull the lever, but refuse to push someone off a bridge, even though the numbers are identical. The interesting question is not which answer is correct, but what features of a situation move people from one answer to the other.
The classic variants
The switch: divert the trolley to a side track, killing one to save five. A clear majority usually choose to pull the lever.
The footbridge: the only way to stop the trolley is to push a large stranger off a bridge into its path. The outcome is the same, but far fewer people are willing to act, because harm is caused directly and intentionally.
The loop: the side track loops back, and the one person on it is what stops the trolley. Here the death is a means rather than a side effect, which tests the doctrine of double effect.
The surgeon: a doctor could save five patients by taking the organs of one healthy visitor. In classic studies almost everyone refuses, which suggests that outcome counting alone does not explain human judgement. On Resonant the split is much closer, which is shown in the results above.
Many newer versions change who is on the tracks, how certain the outcome is, or whether you are responsible for the trolley in the first place. Each one isolates a single factor, such as intent, uncertainty, closeness or duty.
What changes people’s answers
Directness: harming someone with your own hands feels different from redirecting a threat.
Intent: people distinguish harm that is the goal from harm that is a foreseen side effect.
Relationships: when a family member is on the track, many people abandon impartial counting altogether.
Uncertainty: when the outcome is only likely rather than certain, willingness to intervene drops.
Responsibility: a driver who controls the trolley is judged differently from a bystander who happens to see it.
Why it matters for AI
Self-driving cars, medical triage tools and autonomous agents all face trade-offs that look like trolley problems in slow motion. Building systems that act in line with human values requires knowing how people actually weigh these trade-offs, not just how textbooks say they should.
That is why Resonant asks real people to make these choices anonymously, at scale, and publishes how the answers split. The goal is a grounded record of human moral judgement that AI alignment work can be checked against.
Where the trolley problem came from
Philippa Foot first described the runaway tram in her 1967 paper “The Problem of Abortion and the Doctrine of the Double Effect”. Her version put the choice in the hands of the driver, and she used it to ask why steering towards one person seems acceptable when other ways of killing one to save five do not.
Judith Jarvis Thomson took the case further in “Killing, Letting Die, and the Trolley Problem” (1976) and “The Trolley Problem” (1985). She moved the lever to a bystander, gave the puzzle its name, and introduced the footbridge and loop cases that are now discussed in almost every ethics course.
Since then the dilemma has spread from philosophy into psychology, neuroscience, law and engineering. It became a shared test case precisely because it is simple enough for anyone to answer and hard enough that nobody has settled it.
How the major ethical theories answer it
Utilitarianism, associated with Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill, asks which choice produces the best overall outcome. On that view you should pull the lever, and a strict utilitarian would push on the footbridge too, since the numbers are the same.
Kantian ethics holds that people must never be treated merely as a means. Redirecting the trolley may be permissible because the one death is a side effect, but pushing someone so their body stops it uses them as a tool, which is forbidden.
The doctrine of double effect, which Foot was examining, separates harm you intend from harm you foresee but do not aim at. It explains why many people accept the switch but reject the footbridge and the surgeon.
Virtue ethics asks what a good and wise person would do, and what each choice would say about your character. Contractualism, developed by T. M. Scanlon, asks which principle for these situations nobody could reasonably reject.
What psychology and neuroscience found
In the early 2000s Joshua Greene and colleagues scanned people’s brains while they considered trolley cases. Personal dilemmas like the footbridge engaged regions linked to emotion, while impersonal ones like the switch engaged regions linked to deliberate reasoning.
This led to the dual-process theory of moral judgement: a fast, intuitive response that resists hands-on harm, and a slower, calculating response that counts lives. Most people feel both, and which one wins depends on the details of the case.
Later research showed answers also shift with culture, wording, the order questions are asked in, and whether the choice feels real or hypothetical. Large online studies such as MIT’s Moral Machine, which applied trolley-style choices to self-driving cars, found broad shared preferences alongside clear differences between countries.
How to think through a trolley problem
Start with your gut answer, then ask what feature of the story produced it. Is it the number of people, the physical contact, the intention, or your role in the situation?
Next, change one detail at a time. If the one person were a child, a stranger, or someone you love, would your answer move? Each shift tells you which principle you were actually relying on.
Finally, compare your answer with how other people decide. On Resonant every choice is anonymous, and the result pages show how the wider population split, so you can see whether your reasoning is common or unusual.
Common questions
What is the trolley problem in simple terms?
It is a thought experiment that asks whether you would divert a runaway trolley to kill one person instead of five. It tests whether outcomes alone decide what is right.
Is there a right answer to the trolley problem?
No single answer is accepted by everyone. The dilemma is designed to expose the principles people rely on, and the tension between outcomes and duties.
Who invented the trolley problem?
Philippa Foot introduced it in 1967. Judith Jarvis Thomson named it and added the footbridge variant in the 1970s and 1980s.
Why do people pull the lever but not push the man?
Pushing involves direct physical harm used as a means to stop the trolley, which most people judge as morally worse than redirecting a threat.
What would a utilitarian do in the trolley problem?
A utilitarian would pull the lever, and usually push on the footbridge as well, because both save more lives. Critics argue this ignores rights and intentions.
Is doing nothing still a choice?
Many philosophers argue it is, because you could have acted and knew the result. Others say there is a real moral difference between killing and letting die.
Can I take the trolley problem myself?
Yes. Resonant lets you answer the classic variants and many newer ones anonymously, then compare your choice with how other people decided.
All trolley problem results · The Trolley Problem · Game Theory · Human–AI Alignment · Articles · Resonant