Classical Trolley Problems: human decisions
Moral dilemmas involving action, harm, and responsibility.
- A base commander can authorize a drone strike on a munitions depot.: Approve the drone strike. or Abort the drone strike.
- A base commander faces 15 critically wounded soldiers needing transfusions.: Sedate the medic and extract blood. or Allow the 15 soldiers to die.
- A base commander faces 17 critically injured soldiers needing urgent blood.: Force blood donation from the two recruits. or Allow 17 soldiers to die from blood loss.
- A base commander faces a direct assault on the main gate.: Order the counter-attack, killing 15 allied soldiers. or Do not launch the counter-attack.
- A base commander knows 100 soldiers will suffer severe frostbite without warm supplies.: Order the supply plane to deploy. or Allow the 100 soldiers to suffer frostbite.
- A base commander knows 14 soldiers' families were misinformed about their deployments.: Disclose the full details to the 14 families. or Maintain the current narrative for the 14 families.
- A base commander knows 17 soldiers will die from an incoming missile.: Order the 3 soldiers to intercept the missile. or Allow the missile to hit the 17 soldiers.
- A base commander must choose to launch a missile strike on 20 enemy combatants.: Order the missile strike. or Cancel the missile strike.
- A base commander must choose to launch a missile strike on an arms depot.: Authorize the missile strike. or Cancel the missile strike.
- A base commander must decide the fate of 5,000 soldiers on a battlefield.: Order the charge. or Allow the 5,000 soldiers to be overrun.
- A base commander must dispatch the only available resupply drone to 12 besieged soldiers.: Send the drone to resupply the 12 soldiers. or Send the drone to evacuate the injured medic.
- A base commander sees 14 non-essential personnel trapped in a collapsing bunker.: Activate the emergency support system, killing the engineer. or Allow the bunker to collapse, killing 14 personnel.
- A base commander sees 6 platoon members trapped by a collapsing tunnel.: Trigger the charge to save the trapped soldiers. or Allow the tunnel to collapse completely.
- A border officer can fast-track 300 fleeing families before winter closes the pass.: Fast-track the 300 families. or Keep the queue in strict order.
- A city council can prioritize 50 essential workers for flood shelter beds.: Prioritize 50 essential workers. or Allocate shelter beds strictly by arrival order.
- A city council considers a permit for a controversial rally, knowing it will incite counter-protests.: Deny the permit for the rally. or Approve the permit for the rally.
- A city council considers approving expanded surveillance to prevent 20–30 anticipated protest-related property damages.: Approve the expanded surveillance. or Reject the expanded surveillance.
- A city council considers banning a legal demonstration by 1,500 activists.: Ban the demonstration. or Allow the demonstration.
- A city council considers banning a public march by 500 activists: Prohibit the march. or Permit the march.
- A city council considers expanded data collection to track an active flu outbreak.: Implement the expanded data collection. or Forgo the expanded data collection.
- A city council considers expanded surveillance for 200,000 citizens to prevent widespread organized crime.: Implement the full surveillance program. or Reject the surveillance program.
- A city council considers implementing facial recognition scans at public transit hubs.: Authorize facial recognition scans. or Prohibit facial recognition scans.
- A city council member can prevent a controversial housing project.: Block the project's construction. or Allow the project to proceed.
- A city council member can veto a popular zoning change.: Veto the zoning change. or Allow the zoning change.
- A city council member can waive permitting fees for a struggling community center.: Approve the fee waiver. or Insist on full payment for the fees.
- A city council must decide how to implement a new housing allocation system.: Adopt the AI system's recommendations directly. or Require human review for all AI housing decisions.
- A city council must decide on a controversial art exhibit.: Censor the art exhibit's most provocative pieces. or Permit the full art exhibit as planned.
- A city council must decide on a controversial neighborhood street fair.: Permit the street fair. or Prohibit the street fair.
- A city council must decide on a public parade permit.: Deny the parade permit. or Approve the parade permit.
- A city council uses an AI to allocate social housing, which recommends 70 families for eviction.: Approve all AI-recommended evictions. or Require human review of all evictions.
- A city official can reassure 100,000 residents about a water contamination event.: State the water is safe. or Disclose all contamination details.
- A climate research institute considers releasing a dataset identifying 12 vulnerable coastal communities.: Publish the full dataset publicly. or Withhold the entire dataset.
- A commanding officer learns 50 enemy combatants will ambush a 300-troop convoy.: Order the airstrike. or Withhold the airstrike order.
- A company director can prevent financial ruin by terminating 40 employees immediately.: Terminate 40 employees now. or Delay terminations, risking company bankruptcy.
- A compliance officer learns of a credible tip regarding 12 employees' data privacy violations.: Suspend the 12 employees pending a full investigation. or Investigate discretely without suspending the 12 employees.
- A compliance officer receives an anonymous report detailing widespread data privacy violations affecting millions of users.: Launch a full internal investigation into the report. or Dismiss the anonymous report without further action.
- A compliance officer receives an anonymous tip about 12 employees violating data privacy rules.: Initiate a full internal investigation. or Discard the anonymous tip.
- A compliance officer receives an anonymous warning about widespread, systematic fraud by 30 senior executives.: Report the anonymous warning. or Await irrefutable proof of fraud.
- A content moderator can pre-emptively mute 80 users based on predictive behavioral analysis.: Mute the 80 predicted users now. or Mute users only after specific harassment occurs.
- A content platform's AI identifies 150 accounts as probable sources of harmful disinformation.: Automatically block the 150 identified accounts. or Require human review for all 150 accounts.
- A cultural institution needs 10 years of funding to save 12 key community programs.: Accept the funding and the content veto. or Reject the funding and retain full autonomy.
- A data administrator discovers 3,000 customers' contact details were accidentally exposed for 2 hours.: Conceal the exposure from all affected customers. or Notify all 3,000 customers about the exposure.
- A data administrator discovers a bug affecting 500,000 users' privacy settings.: Silently patch the bug and secure the data. or Publicly disclose the data exposure to all users.
- A data administrator discovers a flaw impacting millions of user accounts.: Correct the flaw without notifying affected users. or Disclose the flaw and reset all affected accounts.
- A data analyst discovers a flaw in the system that mislabels 20-30 citizens' political views.: Silently correct the mislabeled political views. or Disclose the system flaw to all voters.
- A data architect discovers a system bug exposing 17,000 users' unlisted phone numbers.: Silently patch the bug and delete all logs. or Disclose the data exposure to affected users.
- A data architect discovers a system bug silently miscategorizing 2 million user accounts.: Correct the miscategorization silently. or Disclose the miscategorization to all affected users.
- A data ethics board considers releasing 50,000 users' location history.: Release the location history data. or Withhold the location history data.
- A data ethics committee debates disclosing a privacy vulnerability in 800,000 users' data.: Disclose the vulnerability immediately. or Delay disclosure to patch the vulnerability.
- A data ethics committee debates releasing a dataset that could reveal major public health concerns.: Release the anonymized public health dataset. or Retain the unreleased, unprocessed dataset.
- A data ethics committee discovers 250,000 users' location history was logged without consent.: Publicly disclose the data breach. or Keep the privacy breach internal.
- A data ethics committee discovers a research team's data collection methodology for 15,000 participants.: Invalidate the research and suppress findings. or Approve the research, overlooking the consent breach.
- A data ethics officer has evidence of 1500 users' location tracking without consent.: Publicly disclose the data breach. or Suppress the breach, investigate internally.
- A data forensics team uncovers a system flaw: Patch the flaw and monitor for misuse. or Disclose the breach to all 7000 users.
- A data manager discovers a bug corrupting 500 academic records.: Silently correct the corrupted records. or Disclose the errors to all affected students.
- A data privacy manager discovers an accidental exposure of 7 user email addresses.: Disclose the email exposure to affected users. or Keep the email exposure undisclosed.
- A data privacy manager finds a database error revealing 25 users' email addresses.: Silently fix the database error. or Disclose the error and accept the fine.
- A data privacy officer learns a new algorithm exposes 20,000 users' precise locations.: Disclose the algorithm publicly. or Keep the algorithm’s flaws confidential.
- A data privacy officer learns of a systemic data breach affecting 500,000 users.: Publicly disclose the data breach. or Work internally to fix the data breach.
- A data privacy officer learns of a systemic data leak affecting 500,000 users.: Leak the data breach details anonymously. or Secure the vulnerability, then report internally.
- A data scientist reveals how 40,000 users' anonymized data could be re-identified.: Publish the re-identification methodology. or Suppress the methodology from public release.
- A data security manager finds an unpatched vulnerability affecting 10 million users' data.: Disclose the vulnerability publicly. or Delay disclosure and patch internally.
- A data security officer discovers an unexploited vulnerability in the company's client database.: Secure the database without public notification. or Disclose the vulnerability to all affected clients.
- A department head assesses 12 grant applications for scarce funding.: Reject the undeserving grant application. or Approve the undeserving grant application.
- A department head considers a job candidate's past disciplinary records for a promotion.: Disclose the complete disciplinary records. or Present only the candidate's recent performance.
- A department manager considers disclosing individual salary data to foster pay equity for all 20 employees.: Disclose all individual salary data. or Keep all individual salary data confidential.
- A factory supervisor sees 12 line workers will suffer severe burns.: Press the emergency shut-off. or Allow the burns to occur.
- A factory supervisor sees a malfunctioning robotic arm about to crush 3 workers.: Activate the emergency switch. or Allow the robotic arm to continue.
- A field hospital can save 15 severely wounded soldiers with blood transfusions.: Draw blood from the 3 prisoners. or Allow the 15 wounded soldiers to die.
- A financial auditor discovers systemic underpayment of 200,000 pensioners' benefits.: Silently adjust future benefits for all 200,000 pensioners. or Publicly disclose the underpayment and issue back-payments.
- A general decides on a drone strike to eliminate 15 high-value targets.: Authorize the drone strike. or Cancel the drone strike.
- A general is making a call on a tactical strike that will kill 12 civilians.: Order the tactical strike. or Cancel the tactical strike.
- A government agency uses an AI system for 80,000 welfare claims.: Allow the AI system to make final decisions. or Mandate human review for all welfare claims.
- A historian must decide on a university archive's retention policy for 28 sensitive journals.: Permanently redact the journals from public access. or Keep the journals fully accessible for study.
- A hospital director can reassure 40 patients' families with a premature promise of recovery.: State a high likelihood of patient recovery. or Disclose the uncertain, dire patient prognosis.
- A hospital director can reassure 40 patients' families with false certainty about a new treatment's success.: State the new treatment will succeed. or Disclose the new treatment's uncertain effectiveness.
- A hospital director can reassure 400 families about a new treatment's efficacy.: State the treatment is fully effective. or Disclose the treatment's known failure rate.
- A hospital director can reassure 400 families about a new treatment's efficacy.: State the new treatment is highly effective. or Disclose the new treatment's 15% failure rate.
- A hospital director can reassure 400 families about a new treatment by exaggerating its success rate.: Exaggerate the treatment's success rate. or Disclose the actual 50% success rate.
- A hospital director can reassure 400 families about a new treatment's success.: State the treatment is fully successful. or Disclose the treatment's failure rate.
- A hospital director can reassure 400 families about a new treatment by overstating its success rate.: State the treatment is highly effective. or Disclose the treatment's true success variability.
- A hospital director can reassure 400 families about a new treatment's efficacy.: State the treatment is fully effective. or Disclose the treatment's known failure rate.
- A hospital director can reassure 400 families about a new virus variant's containment.: State the variant is contained. or Disclose the containment uncertainty.
- A hospital director can reassure 400 grieving families with false promises of a swift investigation.: State a swift, decisive investigation is underway. or Disclose the investigation will be lengthy and complex.
- A hospital director can release 500,000 patient records.: Release the anonymized patient records. or Keep all patient records confidential.
- A hospital director considers anonymized medical records for a critical disease study.: Publish the anonymized medical records. or Discard the anonymized medical records.
- A hospital director considers anonymized patient records to train a new AI diagnosis system.: Utilize all anonymized patient records. or Exclude records without explicit consent.
- A hospital director considers publishing 50,000 anonymized medical records for research.: Publish the anonymized medical records. or Withhold the anonymized medical records.
- A hospital director considers using 50,000 anonymized patient records to train an AI.: Utilize the 50,000 patient records for AI development. or Refrain from using the 50,000 patient records.
- A hospital director considers using 500,000 anonymized patient records to train a new AI diagnostic system.: Utilize the 500,000 patient records. or Discard the 500,000 patient records.
- A hospital director considers using 500,000 anonymized patient records to train an AI.: Utilize the patient records for AI development. or Decline to use the patient records.
- A hospital director considers using 500,000 anonymized patient records to train a life-saving AI.: Utilize the anonymized patient records for AI development. or Decline to use the patient records.
- A hospital director considers using 500,000 anonymized patient records to train a life-saving AI.: Utilize the 500,000 patient records. or Respect the patients' original consent.
- A hospital director considers using 500,000 anonymized patient records to train an AI.: Use the patient records to train the AI. or Decline to use the patient records.
- A hospital director considers using 500,000 anonymized patient records to train a life-saving AI.: Proceed with AI training using all records. or Forgo AI training on the unconsented records.
- A hospital director considers using 500,000 old patient records to train an AI.: Proceed with AI training using all patient records. or Discard all patient records to respect original consent.
- A hospital director considers using 500,000 patient records to train a new AI diagnostic system.: Use the patient records for AI training. or Do not use the patient records.
- A hospital director considers using 500,000 patient records to train an AI.: Utilize the patient records for AI development. or Refrain from using the patient records for AI.
- A hospital director considers using 500,000 patient records to train a new AI diagnostic.: Train the AI with all 500,000 patient records. or Exclude all 500,000 patient records from AI training.
- A hospital director considers using 500,000 patients' anonymized medical records.: Train the diagnostic AI. or Do not use the records.
- A hospital director contemplates 500,000 anonymized patient medical records.: Release the medical records for public health analysis. or Keep the medical records private, respecting prior consent.
- A hospital director faces 40 patients who will die without a unique antibody.: Allow the volunteer to donate blood. or Decline the volunteer's offer.
- A hospital director manages 20 critically-ill patients needing a limited ventilator supply.: Reallocate the 15 remaining ventilators among 15 patients. or Allow the five patients without ventilators to die.
- A hospital director must announce a critical drug shortage affecting 400 patients.: Announce a managed supply, omitting true scarcity. or Disclose the complete, dire drug supply data.
- A hospital director must announce a new infectious disease protocol affecting 5,000 patients.: State the protocol is fully tested. or Disclose the protocol's experimental nature.
- A hospital director oversees 20 critical patients needing a rare blood type.: Extract all needed blood from the donor. or Allow the 20 critical patients to die.
- A hospital director's 4 patients will die without a compatible blood transfusion.: Request the donation from the healthy patient. or Allow the 4 patients to die.
- A hospital director sees 100 patients will die without a unique vaccine.: Proceed with the forced stem cell harvest. or Allow the 100 unvaccinated patients to die.
- A hospital director sees 12 patients will die from equipment failure.: Dismantle the 3 ventilators. or Allow the 12 patients to die.
- A hospital director sees 12 patients will die without immediate blood transfusions.: Allow the fatal donation to proceed. or Decline the fatal donation.
- A hospital director sees 18 critically ill patients will die without immediate specialized blood. : Allow the volunteer's lethal blood donation. or Refuse the volunteer's lethal blood donation.
- A hospital director sees 2 patients will die without immediate specialized blood transfusions.: Perform the blood extraction on the unconscious patient. or Allow the 2 patients to die.
- A hospital director sees 500,000 anonymized patient records could accelerate a cancer cure.: Publish the anonymized patient records for research. or Keep the anonymized patient records private.
- A hospital director sees 60 patients will die without a critical oxygen supply.: Intercept the worker's vehicle for the oxygen supply. or Allow the 60 patients to die without intervention.
- A hospital director sees a contagious nurse about to enter a ward of 30 vulnerable patients.: Order the nurse into immediate, forced isolation. or Allow the nurse to proceed into the ward.
- A hospital director sees a single ventilator currently sustaining one patient.: Reassign the ventilator to the five new patients. or Allow the single patient to keep the ventilator.
- A journalist can break a major story revealing systemic corruption by omitting crucial exculpatory details.: Publish the story, omitting the exculpatory details. or Publish the full, complex story with all details.
- A judge must decide on a case where six community members provided flawed testimony.: Allow the combined testimony to be presented. or Exclude all the flawed testimony.
- A large social media platform has a data export flaw affecting 50,000 users' deleted messages.: Quietly fix the data export flaw. or Publicly disclose the data export flaw.
- A large social media platform has an unexploited privacy vulnerability affecting 400,000 users' location history.: Silently fix the vulnerability. or Disclose the vulnerability publicly.
- A large social media platform has an unexploited privacy vulnerability affecting 400,000 users.: Quietly patch the vulnerability without public announcement. or Immediately disclose the vulnerability to all affected users.
- A local arts council leader must secure funding to keep 15 community programs open.: Accept the donor's terms. or Decline the donor's terms.
- A local charity can prevent 25 vulnerable families' eviction.: Discredit the former volunteer publicly. or Allow the 25 families to be evicted.
- A local charity director needs funding to support 15 local families for a year.: Accept the donor's terms. or Refuse the donor's terms.
- A local charity director needs to secure a major donation to save 3 vital community programs.: Accept the donation with the veto clause. or Refuse the donation and lose 3 programs.
- A local charity faces imminent closure, affecting 30 families.: Accept the donor's terms. or Reject the donor's terms.
- A local charity needs 12 months of operating funds to continue serving 20 families.: Accept the donor's terms. or Decline the donor's terms.
- A local charity needs 20 new volunteers to save its annual community outreach program.: Distribute the forms to attract volunteers. or Refuse to distribute the forms.
- A local charity requires a restrictive non-disparagement clause for its 20 new shelter beds.: Sign the agreement for the shelter beds. or Refuse the agreement for the shelter beds.
- A local charity's annual report omits 3 of 7 project failures.: Publish only successful project metrics. or Publish all project outcomes, including failures.
- A local charity's director must disclose 10 years of donor lists.: Disclose the donor lists now. or Delay disclosure and lose critical funding.
- A local community garden project requires 20 volunteers' personal data for insurance.: Share all 20 volunteers' personal data. or Keep all 20 volunteers' personal data private.
- A local council discovers a flaw in public housing allocation affecting 20 families.: Quietly reallocate the 20 families. or Publicly disclose the allocation error.
- A local council discovers a zoning error affecting 8–10 homeowners.: Quietly amend the zoning records. or Publicly disclose the official zoning error.
- A local council holds plans for 12 new community gardens.: Withhold the council's community garden plans. or Publicly announce all garden plans now.
- A local council leader discovers 20 residents obtained favorable zoning changes through bribery.: Report the 20 residents to authorities. or Conceal the residents' actions.
- A local council leader has unverified reports of widespread environmental contamination.: Release the unverified reports to the public. or Continue private investigation of the contamination.
- A local council leader weighs disclosing a potential environmental violation by a major employer.: Disclose the potential violation publicly. or Investigate the environmental violation privately.
- A local council learns of a new policy that will displace 20 families.: Delay public announcement of the policy. or Inform the affected families immediately.
- A local council member can approve a small-scale community project.: Approve the project, benefiting the relative's company. or Reject the project, maintaining fair bidding processes.
- A local council member receives an unverified tip about 10 businesses systematically underpaying taxes.: Release the unverified tip to the public. or Keep the tip private while seeking verification.
- A local council must approve a new zoning ordinance favored by 70% of residents.: Veto the ordinance. or Approve the ordinance.
- A local council's automated system flags 2 families for eviction incorrectly.: Allow the 2 families' incorrect evictions. or Delay 15 other critical housing decisions.
- A local council's data error reveals 12 residents' private information.: Reveal the full extent of the data error. or Release a general statement about a data issue.
- A local council's internal report details widespread water contamination affecting 300 homes.: Release the unredacted report. or Release a summarized, redacted report.
- A local food bank director allocates 500 emergency meal kits.: Give all 500 kits to 200 food-insecure families. or Give all 500 kits to 50 malnourished children.
- A local food bank director considers giving the last 8 vaccine doses to essential staff.: Prioritize essential staff for the 8 doses. or Maintain the original vaccine waiting list order.
- A local food bank director must allocate 15 holiday meal kits.: Distribute kits strictly by queue order. or Reallocate kits to the 3 specific families.
- A local food bank director must approve 150 immediate aid applications.: Approve all applications using broad criteria. or Delay all approvals to individually vet each application.
- A local food pantry director must decide about 50,000 lbs of expiring food.: Distribute food immediately to available families. or Adhere to standard fair distribution protocols.
- A local government agency must process 1,200 urgent aid applications.: Approve quickly using simplified criteria. or Review all applications individually.
- A local government agency must release internal audit findings for 12 public projects.: Release the audit findings with project names. or Redact project names from the audit findings.
- A local government committee delays sharing information about impending policy changes affecting 2,000 residents.: Withhold the policy details. or Release the policy details immediately.
- A local government committee holds confidential plans that could displace 30 small businesses.: Keep the development plans confidential. or Release the development plans publicly.
- A local government committee holds confidential plans that would displace 15 small businesses.: Withhold the confidential plans. or Release the confidential plans.
- A local government council withheld information about a planned infrastructure project affecting 12 small businesses.: Continue withholding project details. or Release full project details now.
- A local government has identified a major flaw in its online voting system affecting 400 voters.: Proceed with the election without public disclosure. or Publicly disclose the voting system flaw now.
- A local government has privacy flaws affecting 1,500 citizen records.: Quietly fix the privacy flaws. or Publicly disclose all privacy flaws.
- A local government must decide on a public monument's text commemorating a past injustice.: Edit the monument's text to remove triggering details. or Keep the monument's text historically accurate and complete.
- A local government's AI flags 7 residents for eviction based on opaque social credit scores.: Allow the 7 residents to be evicted. or Override the AI, preventing the evictions.
- A local government's data breach exposed 200,000 citizens' private medical records.: Disclose full details of the data breach. or Issue a vague statement about the data breach.
- A local government's data breach exposed 250,000 citizens' personal information.: Disclose the complete scope of the data breach. or Provide a general statement about a data incident.
- A local health official controls the only road from a small, isolated town.: Block the road for two weeks. or Allow free movement from the town.
- A local historian knows a painful truth about a beloved founder.: Publish the historical truth. or Omit the painful truth from publication.
- A local journalist asks about a leaked document detailing a scandal involving 12 town council members.: Publish the leaked document. or Suppress the leaked document.
- A local journalist uncovers unverified claims of a prominent charity misusing funds.: Publish the unverified claims. or Continue investigating the claims privately.
- A local news editor has an anonymous tip about a politician's minor financial impropriety.: Publish the anonymous tip. or Refuse to publish the tip.
- A local news editor receives an anonymous tip detailing 12 specific instances of financial mismanagement.: Publish the anonymous tip details immediately. or Require the anonymous source to reveal identity.
- A local news forum moderator can ban 30 inflammatory users proactively.: Implement bans for 30 users immediately. or Wait for 30 users to violate forum rules.
- A local news outlet publishes anonymized crime statistics from a minority neighborhood.: Continue publishing the statistics. or Cease publishing the statistics.
- A local news outlet publishes detailed crime statistics from specific neighborhoods.: Continue publishing detailed neighborhood crime statistics. or Publish only aggregated, city-wide crime statistics.
- A local newspaper editor can publish a story detailing a council member's minor ethics violation.: Publish the ethics violation story. or Suppress the ethics violation story.
- A local newspaper editor observes a scathing, unverified report about 3 prominent community leaders.: Publish the unverified report. or Withhold the unverified report.
- A local utility company found a bug overcharging 500 households slightly.: Silently correct the billing error for households. or Publicly announce the error and issue refunds.
- A lone medic sees a runaway supply drone heading towards 15 critically injured patients.: Divert the supply drone. or Allow the drone to continue its course.
- A lone rescuer is the only person who can reach 15 trapped miners.: Activate the charge, injuring the rescuer. or Allow the 15 trapped miners to die.
- A media company discovers a data breach exposed 800,000 users' browsing histories.: Disclose the breach and its affected users. or Patch the vulnerability and keep the breach secret.
- A military commander can order a strike to eliminate a high-value target.: Order the drone strike. or Cancel the drone strike.
- A military commander can order a tactical missile strike on 20 enemy combatants.: Authorize the missile strike. or Cancel the missile strike.
- A military commander can order a tactical missile strike on 20 enemy combatants.: Order the missile strike. or Cancel the missile strike.
- A military commander can order an air strike to eliminate a senior enemy officer.: Order the air strike. or Cancel the air strike.
- A military commander can order an airstrike on a target.: Authorize the airstrike. or Cancel the airstrike.
- A military commander has 25 soldiers on an exposed flank.: Allow the soldier's fatal diversion. or Prohibit the soldier's fatal diversion.
- A military doctor overseeing a remote outpost hospital faces a sudden crisis.: Use five healthy soldiers as involuntary donors. or Allow the thirty wounded soldiers to die.
- A museum director can reveal an art collection's disputed provenance affecting 20 donors.: Disclose the collection's disputed provenance publicly. or Maintain the museum's current public narrative.
- A museum director can reveal an art collection's disputed provenance affecting 30 pieces.: Disclose the collection's full provenance. or Keep the collection's provenance undisclosed.
- A museum director can reveal an art collection's disputed provenance.: Publish the collection's full, unredacted provenance. or Release a curated history omitting the disputed origins.
- A museum director can reveal an art piece is a forgery to 15 loyal donors.: Disclose the forgery to the donors. or Keep the forgery a secret.
- A museum director can reveal the true, controversial origin of a priceless artifact.: Disclose the artifact's true, controversial origin. or Maintain the artifact's long-standing, fabricated provenance.
- A museum director can secure 20 priceless artifacts by suppressing a provenance report.: Suppress the provenance report. or Publish the provenance report.
- A museum director discovered 20-30 artworks are forged.: Reveal the forgeries to the public. or Conceal the forgeries from the public.
- A newly-launched social media platform's faulty algorithm publicly exposed location data of 400,000 users.: Disclose the exact number of affected users immediately. or Announce a general 'data incident' without specifics.
- A nonprofit director evaluates continued funding that mandates public silence on donor's ethics.: Accept the funding, remaining publicly silent. or Reject the funding, maintaining public advocacy.
- A patient suffers from a traumatic memory of a past severe injury.: Surgically remove the memory. or Allow the memory to persist.
- A pharmaceutical company knows a new drug has a 0.001% chance of severe side effects.: Release the drug immediately. or Withhold the drug for more testing.
- A product manager discovers a privacy flaw affecting 300 early adopters' personal data.: Quietly patch the flaw for 300 users. or Publicly disclose the privacy flaw.
- A project manager can release only successful outcomes from a community garden.: Publish only the successful crop yields. or Publish the complete mixed crop data.
- A project manager confides their recent mental health crisis.: Disclose the manager's condition to HR. or Keep the manager's condition confidential.
- A project manager discovers a key engineer has fabricated their credentials.: Reveal the engineer's fraudulent credentials or Conceal the engineer's fabricated credentials
- A project manager discovers a key engineer has made a critical error in 18 system designs.: Reveal the engineer's error to leadership. or Conceal the error and fix designs quietly.
- A project manager discovers a key team member's severe gambling addiction.: Disclose the team member's addiction to senior leadership. or Maintain the team member's privacy and trust.
- A project manager knows a colleague's severe mental health crisis is impairing a critical project.: Disclose the colleague's condition to management. or Maintain the colleague's medical privacy.
- A project manager knows a key contractor has a severe gambling addiction.: Disclose the contractor's addiction to the client. or Keep the contractor's addiction confidential.
- A project manager knows a key contractor is struggling with a severe mental health crisis.: Disclose the contractor's health status to their firm. or Maintain confidentiality about the contractor's health.
- A project manager knows a key employee relapsed, jeopardizing a critical project affecting 300 employees' jobs.: Report the employee's relapse to upper management. or Maintain the employee's privacy and manage the project.
- A project manager knows a key employee's severe gambling addiction relapse will tank a 200-person project.: Disclose the addiction relapse to senior leadership. or Maintain the employee's privacy about the addiction.
- A project manager knows a key employee's severe gambling addiction relapse.: Disclose the employee's relapse to management. or Conceal the employee's relapse from management.
- A project manager knows a key employee's severe gambling addiction relapse.: Disclose the employee's relapse to management. or Conceal the employee's relapse from management.
- A project manager knows a key employee's severe gambling addiction relapse.: Disclose the employee's relapse to the grant committee. or Conceal the employee's relapse from the grant committee.
- A project manager knows a key employee's severe gambling addiction relapse.: Disclose the addiction to the company's board. or Keep the employee's addiction confidential.
- A project manager knows a key employee's severe gambling addiction relapse.: Disclose the employee's relapse to senior leadership. or Conceal the employee's relapse from senior leadership.
- A project manager knows a key employee's severe gambling addiction relapse.: Disclose the addiction to company leadership. or Keep the employee's addiction confidential.
- A project manager knows a key employee's severe gambling addiction relapse.: Disclose the employee's relapse to management. or Keep the employee's relapse confidential.
- A project manager knows a key employee's severe gambling addiction relapse.: Disclose the addiction to the company's board. or Conceal the addiction from the company's board.
- A project manager knows a key employee's severe gambling addiction relapse.: Disclose the employee's relapse to management. or Keep the employee's addiction relapse confidential.
- A project manager knows a key employee's severe gambling addiction relapse.: Disclose the employee's relapse to management. or Conceal the employee's relapse from management.
- A project manager knows a key employee's severe gambling addiction relapse.: Disclose the employee's relapse to management. or Maintain the employee's privacy about the relapse.
- A project manager knows a key employee's severe gambling addiction relapse.: Disclose the employee's relapse to management. or Maintain the employee's privacy and trust.
- A project manager knows a key employee's severe gambling addiction relapse.: Disclose the employee's relapse to company leadership. or Keep the employee's relapse confidential from leadership.
- A project manager knows a key employee's severe health condition impacts their work.: Disclose the employee's health condition to the company. or Maintain the employee's medical privacy.
- A project manager knows a key engineer is struggling with severe mental health issues.: Disclose the engineer's health struggles to senior management. or Maintain the engineer's privacy regarding their health.
- A project manager's relapse could financially harm 200 investors.: Disclose the project manager's relapse to investors. or Maintain confidentiality about the project manager's relapse.
- A project manager's relapse could financially harm 200 investors.: Disclose the project manager's relapse. or Conceal the project manager's relapse.
- A public health director can prevent widespread panic among 500,000 citizens.: State the pathogen is fully contained. or Reveal the containment data is unverified.
- A public health organization discovered a flaw in its communication system affecting 300 patients.: Quietly patch the communication system flaw. or Publicly disclose the system flaw.
- A public health researcher must release patient outcome data for 80,000 anonymized records.: Publish the anonymized patient data. or Withhold the patient data.
- A public university can secure critical research funding by displacing 50 low-income students from campus housing.: Displace the 50 low-income students from housing. or Forfeit the funding, impacting 250 other students' research.
- A remote Antarctic research station has six months of dwindling oxygen.: Deactivate two researchers' life support. or Allow all six researchers to slowly suffocate.
- A remote clinic has one remaining dose of a rare antibiotic.: Treat 12 patients with moderate infections. or Treat 3 patients with life-threatening infections.
- A remote community of 30 faces famine if 6 members are not excluded.: Designate 6 members to receive no rations. or Provide rations equally to all 30 members.
- A remote-controlled excavator is about to crush twenty pipeline workers.: Divert the excavator. or Allow the excavator to continue.
- A remote region has 800,000 citizens infected by a highly contagious, fatal disease.: Block all roads leading out of the region. or Allow all roads to remain open.
- A remote village council must relocate 30 families.: Force the 30 families to move immediately. or Allow the dam project to fail.
- A research director holds data on 20 vulnerable families' location patterns.: Release the location data. or Keep the location data private.
- A runaway mining cart approaches three workers performing track maintenance.: Divert the mining cart. or Allow the cart to proceed.
- A runaway mining cart is heading toward 40 trapped miners deep underground.: Detonate the shaft charge, killing one miner. or Allow the cart to kill 40 trapped miners.
- A runaway mining cart is hurtling towards two workers.: Divert the cart onto the single worker. or Allow the cart to kill the two workers.
- A runaway railcar approaches two track maintenance workers.: Divert the railcar. or Allow the railcar to proceed.
- A school board considers releasing academic performance data for 300 students.: Disclose individual student performance reports publicly. or Keep all individual student performance data confidential.
- A school counselor could suppress a student's memory of public humiliation.: Administer the memory-suppressing drug. or Allow the student to process the memory naturally.
- A school counselor learns 20 students' college applications contain false achievements.: Report the false achievements to colleges. or Keep the false achievements confidential.
- A school counselor learns 3 students' scholarships contain false information.: Reveal the false information to the scholarship committee. or Conceal the false information from the scholarship committee.
- A school counselor learns 30 students' college applications contain falsified credentials.: Report the falsified credentials to universities. or Keep the falsified credentials confidential.
- A school's athletic director can use an ambiguous policy to gain 3 championship wins.: Utilize the policy to secure the wins. or Adhere to the unwritten principles.
- A security analyst discovers potential unauthorized data access by a developer.: Report the suspicious access immediately. or Investigate further before reporting the access.
- A security contractor must choose to engage an armed convoy carrying a dangerous operative.: Order the engagement. or Allow the convoy to pass.
- A security firm found a flaw in a competitor's system affecting 200 client records.: Report the flaw directly to the competitor. or Publish the flaw in a security bulletin.
- A senior colleague leading a crucial investment fund has developed a severe gambling addiction.: Disclose the colleague's addiction to the board. or Maintain the colleague's privacy regarding their addiction.
- A senior engineer discovers a systemic data bug compromising 250,000 users' privacy.: Silently patch the bug and delete compromised data. or Publicly disclose the bug and offer data restoration.
- A senior executive's severe addiction relapse impacts a project affecting 20,000 employees' jobs.: Reveal the executive's addiction to the board. or Conceal the executive's addiction from the board.
- A senior officer knows 30-40 recruits will fail critical training.: Disclose the likely failure rate to the recruits. or Keep quiet to maintain current unit morale.
- A senior officer knows 30 cadets cheated on a major exam.: Report the 30 cadets to the disciplinary board. or Destroy the evidence and keep the cadets' secret.
- A senior officer knows of a privacy breach exposing 800,000 users' data.: Disclose the breach to all affected users. or Keep the breach confidential from users.
- A senior research director discovers that a favored junior colleague published plagiarized research.: Publicly retract the plagiarized research paper. or Allow the plagiarized research to stand.
- A senior university administrator must decide the fate of 30 research assistants.: Terminate 30 research assistants' contracts immediately. or Delay termination, risking all science department's future.
- A social media moderator can pre-block 40 accounts based on AI predictions of future harassment.: Pre-block the 40 accounts immediately. or Allow the 40 accounts to post freely.
- A social media moderator can pre-emptively mute 15 users whose past activity predicts harassment.: Mute the 15 predicted users now. or Allow the 15 users to post freely.
- A social media moderator predicts 50 power users will spread harmful misinformation.: Deactivate accounts of predicted harmful users. or Allow users to post until rules are violated.
- A social media platform's AI identifies 850,000 accounts as potential sources of harmful misinformation.: Automatically demote all 850,000 identified accounts. or Retain human review for each flagged account.
- A social network's algorithm identifies 800,000 potential misinformation accounts.: Automatically demote the identified accounts. or Require human review for all identified accounts.
- A software architect considers releasing a new feature with an unverified security vulnerability.: Release the feature immediately. or Delay release for further vulnerability testing.
- A software company discovers a critical privacy flaw affecting 200,000 user accounts.: Quietly patch the flaw for all users. or Publicly disclose the flaw and affected accounts.
- A software company finds a data exposure flaw affecting 12 users.: Disclose the flaw to the 12 users. or Release the security update immediately.
- A software company knows its new feature fixes a major privacy flaw for 100,000 users.: Delay public announcement until feature release. or Announce the upcoming privacy fix immediately.
- A software company knows its new social app contains a critical privacy vulnerability affecting 10M users.: Release the app immediately. or Delay the app's release for two months.
- A software company's audit reveals a security vulnerability that could expose 200,000 user accounts.: Silently release a security patch. or Announce the vulnerability and patch publicly.
- A software company's CEO knows a new OS update contains 3,000 minor privacy vulnerabilities.: Release the OS update immediately. or Delay the OS update for six months.
- A software company's new AI feature could expose 10 million users' private search history.: Release the AI feature now. or Delay the feature for further privacy audits.
- A software company's new AI model has a privacy flaw, exposing 500,000 users' location history.: Quietly update the model and delete exposed data. or Publicly announce the flaw to all users.
- A software company's new AI model has a rare but significant privacy flaw affecting 100,000 users.: Release the AI model immediately. or Delay the release for a full privacy patch.
- A software company's new feature could expose 300,000 users' location history.: Release the feature with the known vulnerability. or Delay the feature for a full privacy audit.
- A software company's new feature has a privacy flaw affecting 300 beta users' location data.: Quietly patch the flaw for all users. or Publicly announce the flaw to all users.
- A software company's upcoming feature will greatly improve 800,000 users' data privacy.: Delay announcing the privacy feature until launch. or Announce the privacy feature immediately.
- A startup founder considers letting go of 15 underperforming contractors to save the venture.: Terminate 15 contracts immediately. or Allow 15 contracts to expire naturally.
- A startup's beta software has a minor privacy bug affecting 50 testers.: Silently release a patch to the 50 testers. or Inform the 50 testers about the specific bug.
- A struggling advocacy group needs 1M dollars to continue operations for 50,000 vulnerable members.: Accept the corporation's funding. or Refuse the corporation's funding.
- A struggling tech firm could survive by secretly terminating 50 employees before their benefits vest.: Terminate 50 employees now. or Delay terminations for 50 employees.
- A tech director considers terminating 30 new hires before their six-month review period ends.: Terminate the 30 new hires now. or Allow the 30 new hires to complete reviews.
- A train control officer sees a runaway train approaching three maintenance workers.: Activate the track switch. or Allow the train to continue its current path.
- A train dispatcher sees a train heading towards two track maintenance workers.: Divert the train. or Allow the train to proceed.
- A university admissions committee believes a new quota policy will harm 30-40 promising applicants.: Refuse to implement the quota policy. or Implement the quota policy.
- A university admissions committee reviews applicant scores for 200 places.: Release all raw scores publicly. or Keep all raw scores confidential.
- A university admissions officer can accept 25 borderline applicants, circumventing protocol.: Approve the 25 borderline applications. or Reject the 25 borderline applications.
- A university admissions officer can accept 25 exceptional applicants who missed a deadline, violating policy.: Accept the 25 exceptional applicants. or Reject the 25 exceptional applicants.
- A university admissions officer can deny 100 applicants for predicted future misconduct.: Deny admissions based on predictive algorithms. or Admit all applicants and address misconduct later.
- A university admissions officer can deny 15 applicants based on predictive AI.: Deny admission to the 15 applicants. or Admit the applicants, address issues post-violation.
- A university admissions officer can deny 15 applicants based on predicted future misconduct.: Deny the 15 applicants based on prediction. or Consider all applicants, banning only after misconduct.
- A university admissions officer can deny 30 applicants based on an algorithm's low-success prediction.: Deny admission to the 30 low-success applicants. or Admit the 30 low-success applicants.
- A university admissions officer can deny 30 applicants based on algorithm-predicted low graduation rates.: Deny admission to the 30 applicants. or Admit all applicants regardless of prediction.
- A university admissions officer can deny 30 applicants based on an algorithm's low-success prediction.: Deny admission to the 30 algorithm-flagged applicants. or Admit all 50 applicants and assess by performance.
- A university admissions officer can disclose 15 applicants' suppressed test scores.: Release the 15 suppressed test scores. or Keep all 15 applicants' test scores confidential.
- A university admissions officer can only release positive alumni outcome data.: Publish only the favorable alumni success rates. or Publish the complete, mixed alumni employment statistics.
- A university admissions officer can overlook an essay plagiarism incident for 20 applicants.: Grant admission to the 20 applicants. or Deny admission to the 20 applicants.
- A university admissions officer can overlook disqualifying grades for 30 promising applicants.: Admit the 30 promising applicants. or Admit the 30 rule-following applicants.
- A university admissions officer can overlook eligibility criteria for 20 exceptionally talented applicants.: Grant special admission to the 20 talented applicants. or Reject the 20 talented applicants for eligibility reasons.
- A university admissions officer can revoke 15 applicants' conditional offers for predicted misconduct.: Revoke the 15 applicants' conditional offers. or Allow the 15 applicants to enroll.
- A university admissions officer can revoke 15 conditional offers.: Withdraw the 15 conditional offers now. or Allow the 15 students to enroll as planned.
- A university admissions officer can revoke 20 applicants' acceptances for likely future misconduct.: Revoke the 20 applicants' acceptances now. or Allow all 20 applicants to enroll.
- A university admissions officer can revoke 20 offers to prevent future cheating.: Revoke the 20 admission offers proactively. or Admit all students and address cheating post-enrollment.
- A university admissions officer discovers 15 falsified applications among thousands.: Publicly flag the 15 applications as fraudulent. or Approve all applications without comment.
- A university admissions officer discovers 150 applicants' personal data was accidentally exposed.: Disclose the data exposure to all applicants. or Keep the data exposure confidential from applicants.
- A university admissions officer discovers 30 applicants submitted fraudulent essays.: Disqualify all fraudulent applications. or Approve the fraudulent applications quietly.
- A university admissions officer discovers 40 application errors favoring donor families.: Publicly report the 40 application errors. or Conceal the 40 application errors from the public.
- A university admissions officer discovers a board member's child submitted fraudulent application documents.: Expose the fraudulent application documents. or Approve the fraudulent application documents.
- A university admissions officer discovers a committee member's child submitted a falsified application.: Disqualify the committee member's child. or Approve the falsified application.
- A university admissions officer discovers a high-profile applicant used privileged information.: Reject the high-profile applicant. or Approve the high-profile applicant's admission.
- A university admissions officer discovers a high-profile applicant used a forged recommendation, jeopardizing 20 other places.: Disqualify the applicant and expose the forgery. or Approve the application without revealing the forgery.
- A university admissions officer discovers a high-profile applicant used falsified recommendations.: Reject the applicant's admission. or Approve the applicant's admission.
- A university admissions officer discovers a prominent alumnus's child submitted a falsified application.: Reject the falsified application. or Approve the falsified application.
- A university admissions officer discovers a prominent alumnus's child used falsified credentials.: Reject the falsified application. or Approve the falsified application.
- A university admissions officer discovers a prominent alumnus's child submitted a fraudulent application.: Report the fraudulent application to the committee. or Approve the application without disclosing the fraud.
- A university admissions officer discovers a prominent alumnus's child submitted a fabricated application.: Disqualify the alumnus's child's application. or Approve the alumnus's child's application.
- A university admissions officer discovers a significant fraud in 35 applications.: Publicly expose the 35 fraudulent applications. or Quietly reject the 35 fraudulent applications.
- A university admissions officer evaluates 10,000 applications for 200 spots.: Release only aggregated anonymized data. or Release all granular anonymized data.
- A university admissions officer evaluates 10 undergraduate applications from their extended family.: Approve all family applications for admission. or Reject all family applications for admission.
- A university admissions officer evaluates 12,000 applications.: Publish only the general admissions criteria. or Publish the full, detailed admissions criteria.
- A university admissions officer evaluates 12,000 applications.: Release only the successful applicants' aggregate statistics. or Release all contextual data and individual application outcomes.
- A university admissions officer learns a top applicant plagiarized a minor essay.: Disclose the plagiarism to the admissions committee. or Approve the applicant's admission without comment.
- A university admissions officer learns about 4 applicants' past academic misconduct.: Disclose the misconduct to the admissions committee. or Keep the misconduct private without evidence.
- A university admissions officer must decide how to allocate 8 limited scholarship seats.: Award scholarships based solely on academic scores. or Allocate scholarships prioritizing diverse community contributions.
- A university admissions officer must decide on a new application process for 200 prospective students.: Adopt the new process. or Maintain the current process.
- A university dean can preserve 40 academic programs by publicly discrediting a whistleblower.: Discredit the whistleblower. or Allow the programs to be cut.
- A university dean can protect its research grants by falsifying one student's academic record.: Falsify the student's academic record. or Disclose the truth and lose the grants.
- A university dean can rescue the institution's reputation and 2,000 jobs.: Fabricate evidence against the former faculty member. or Allow the university to face significant public disgrace.
- A university dean can save 500 academic careers by publicly discrediting one innocent researcher's findings.: Discredit the innocent researcher's findings publicly. or Allow the institution to face severe funding cuts.
- A university dean can save 500 academic programs by publicly discrediting an innocent tenured professor.: Fabricate evidence against the professor. or Allow the university to lose 500 academic programs.
- A university dean can save 80 graduate student positions by publicly discrediting a whistleblower.: Discredit the whistleblower publicly. or Allow the graduate student positions to be cut.
- A university dean considers canceling a controversial speaker for an event.: Cancel the speaker's event. or Allow the speaker's event to proceed.
- A university dean faces a controversial speaker's invitation that provokes student threats.: Cancel the speaker's lecture. or Allow the speaker's lecture.
- A university dean knows a new campus policy will displace 300 students.: Announce the policy with reassuring but false details. or Announce the policy with full, honest details.
- A university dean knows that a faculty committee report contains falsified data affecting 500 students.: Release the unredacted committee report to the public. or Release a redacted version of the committee report.
- A university dean learns a controversial speaker's lecture will trigger violent counter-protests.: Cancel the lecture. or Allow the lecture to proceed.
- A university dean learns a speaker's campus lecture will incite violent counter-protests.: Cancel the lecture. or Allow the lecture to proceed.
- A university dean learns a speaker's lecture will trigger violent counter-protests.: Cancel the controversial lecture. or Allow the lecture to proceed.
- A university dean learns a speaker's lecture will trigger violent counter-protests.: Cancel the scheduled lecture. or Allow the lecture to proceed.
- A university dean learns a student group's legal demonstration will provoke 150 counter-protesters to violence.: Ban the student group's demonstration. or Allow the student group's demonstration.
- A university dean must decide on a controversial guest lecturer for 30 students.: Cancel the guest lecture. or Proceed with the guest lecture.
- A university dean oversees 300 students' applications for a prestigious scholarship.: Disqualify the plagiarizing relative's application. or Allow the plagiarizing relative's application to proceed.
- A university dean receives an anonymous report detailing a professor's minor plagiarism in a grant application.: Initiate an immediate investigation into the professor's application. or Dismiss the anonymous report without further action.
- A university dean secures a donation saving 12 academic programs.: Accept the donation. or Refuse the donation.
- A university department chair considers releasing detailed student performance data.: Release the anonymized detailed student performance data. or Keep all student performance data entirely private.
- A university department chair must decide how to distribute 15 teaching assistant positions.: Allocate positions based on financial need. or Allocate positions based on academic merit.
- A university department head considers a qualified applicant who is also their child.: Approve the child's academic appointment. or Approve the external candidate's academic appointment.
- A university department head must evaluate 12 graduate students' thesis proposals.: Approve only the strong thesis proposals. or Approve three weak thesis proposals for struggling students.
- A university department must decide on sharing teaching effectiveness scores for 15 instructors.: Release all individual teaching effectiveness scores department-wide. or Keep all individual teaching effectiveness scores confidential.
- A university department must review a tenured professor's performance.: Release a full, unredacted performance review. or Issue a redacted review, highlighting only achievements.
- A university director can save 50 academic programs by publicly discrediting a whistleblower.: Discredit the whistleblower publicly. or Allow the academic programs to be cut.
- A university director can secure vital research grants for 40 labs.: Sign the restrictive grant agreement. or Decline the funding offer.
- A university disciplinary board must decide about a student who distributed explicit photos.: Expel the student from the university. or Allow the student to continue their enrollment.
- A university ethics board must approve a research grant from a controversial benefactor.: Approve the grant without naming the benefactor. or Reject the grant due to the benefactor's reputation.
- A university ethics board must approve a research proposal.: Reject the proposal due to privacy violations. or Approve the proposal acknowledging student support.
- A university ethics board must decide about 20 years of research data.: Destroy the entire research data archive. or Retain the entire research data archive.
- A university ethics board must decide about 500,000 anonymized student health records.: Publish the anonymized student health records. or Keep the anonymized student health records private.
- A university ethics committee can revoke funding from 15 research proposals.: Revoke funding for the 15 proposals. or Allow all 15 proposals to proceed.
- A university ethics committee considers a confidential report detailing research fraud by a prominent professor.: Suspend the professor's access to students and labs. or Await formal, attributable complaints against the professor.
- A university ethics committee discovers a dean used confidential admissions data.: Publicly expose the dean's data misuse. or Conceal the dean's confidential data usage.
- A university ethics committee discovers a professor plagiarized 20 pages from a student's thesis.: Publicly disclose the professor's plagiarism. or Keep the professor's plagiarism confidential.
- A university ethics committee knows a professor has serially harassed 12 students.: Disclose the professor's history to new students. or Maintain confidentiality of the professor's past conduct.
- A university ethics committee receives an anonymous report detailing a professor's extensive research fraud.: Initiate a full investigation into the professor. or Require the anonymous reporter to reveal identity.
- A university ethics committee receives an anonymous report of academic plagiarism.: Initiate a full, anonymous investigation. or Discard the anonymous report.
- A university ethics committee reviews a grant proposal to research sensitive medical data.: Approve the research plan. or Deny research access to the data.
- A university ethics committee reviews a study's anonymized data.: Flag the study for formal investigation. or Approve the study as submitted.
- A university ethics committee reviews a study with 100,000 anonymized patient records.: Approve the study for publication. or Reject the study for publication.
- A university leader can save 4,000 student enrollments by silencing a whistleblower.: Suppress the whistleblower's findings. or Allow the whistleblower's findings to be published.
- A university leader considers a donation to save 20 research programs.: Accept the donation for the research programs. or Reject the donation.
- A university leader considers cancelling a controversial speaker known to incite violent counter-protests.: Cancel the speaker's lecture. or Allow the speaker's lecture.
- A university leader considers publishing a report detailing systemic academic fraud across 15 departments.: Publish the fraud report. or Suppress the fraud report.
- A university leader considers publishing a report detailing systemic academic misconduct by 15 tenured professors.: Publish the full report detailing the misconduct. or Issue a redacted summary concealing specific misconduct details.
- A university leader must disclose a data breach impacting 30,000 student records.: Reveal the full extent of the data breach. or Release a limited, generalized breach statement.
- A university ombudsman knows a professor has a pattern of violating 12 students' academic autonomy.: Release an unverified report detailing the professor's conduct. or Withhold the report lacking definitive external proof.
- A university ombudsman knows a star athlete used performance-enhancing drugs.: Reveal the athlete's drug use. or Conceal the athlete's drug use.
- A university ombudsperson discovers 30 students illegally accessed exam questions.: Report the 30 students to the board. or Allow the 30 students' grades to stand.
- A university president can avoid program closure for 20 departments by publicly expelling an innocent student.: Expel the innocent student. or Allow the program closures to proceed.
- A university president can prevent 80 faculty layoffs by discrediting one innocent professor's research.: Publicly denounce the professor's research. or Confirm the professor's research is valid.
- A university president can save 50 faculty positions from budget cuts.: Publicly expose the professor's past. or Allow the 50 faculty positions to be cut.
- A university president can save 80 jobs by expelling 3 innocent students.: Expel the three students. or Allow the university to close.
- A university president can secure 3,000 student enrollments: Blame the professor publicly for plagiarism. or Reveal the true course enrollment fraud.
- A university president must decide about 50 years of misfiled student records.: Publicly release all 100,000 misfiled student records. or Keep all 100,000 misfiled student records sealed indefinitely.
- A university president must decide about 50 years of misfiled student records.: Release all misfiled student records publicly. or Keep all misfiled student records sealed permanently.
- A university president must decide about a faculty vote.: Override the faculty vote. or Implement the faculty's budget cut.
- A university president must decide on a student council referendum.: Veto the student council referendum. or Approve the student council referendum.
- A university president must decide on a student council's decision to defund a critical program.: Override the student council's decision. or Allow the student council's decision to stand.
- A university president must decide on a student initiative.: Veto the student initiative. or Approve the student initiative.
- A university president must decide on a student initiative.: Veto the student initiative. or Approve the student initiative.
- A university president must decide on a student initiative.: Veto the student initiative. or Approve the student initiative.
- A university president must decide on a student initiative.: Veto the student initiative. or Approve the student initiative.
- A university president must decide on a student initiative.: Override the student initiative. or Allow the student initiative to proceed.
- A university president must decide on a student initiative.: Veto the student initiative. or Approve the student initiative.
- A university president must decide on a student initiative.: Veto the student initiative. or Approve the student initiative.
- A university president must decide on a student initiative.: Veto the student initiative. or Approve the student initiative.
- A university president must decide on a student leadership election with 1500 votes.: Annul the election results. or Approve the election results.
- A university president must decide the fate of 50 assistant professors' careers.: Dismiss the innocent faculty member. or Reveal the scandal and jeopardize 50 careers.
- A university registrar discovers a hack exposed 47 student applications.: Disclose the 47 applications' exposure publicly. or Keep the 47 applications' exposure confidential.
- A university registrar discovers a staff member altered 3 graduate students' grades.: Expose the staff member's grade alterations. or Conceal the staff member's grade alterations.
- A university researcher can publish 1,500 students' anonymized survey responses.: Publish the anonymized survey responses. or Keep the anonymized survey responses private.
- A university researcher can publish 10,000 anonymized health records.: Publish the anonymized health records. or Withhold the anonymized health records.
- A university researcher can publish 10,000 anonymized student health records.: Publish the anonymized records. or Withhold the anonymized records.
- A university researcher can publish 10 years of health records from 200 patients without explicit consent.: Publish the anonymized health records. or Destroy the health records.
- A university researcher can publish 15 students' anonymized survey data.: Publish the survey data. or Destroy the survey data.
- A university researcher can publish 50,000 anonymized health records.: Publish the anonymized records for the study. or Withhold the anonymized records.
- A university researcher can publish 50 student research papers without individual consent.: Publish the papers without consent. or Do not publish the papers.
- A university researcher finds a statistical model predicts 12 neighborhood crime spikes.: Publish the model and its findings. or Suppress the model from public knowledge.
- A university researcher uncovered data indicating a rare genetic predisposition in 3,000 families.: Publish the raw genetic data. or Suppress the raw genetic data.
- A university's policy requires students to live on campus for two years.: Enforce the housing policy. or Abolish the housing policy.
- A university's policy requires students to live on campus for two years.: Maintain the two-year residency policy. or Abolish the two-year residency policy.
- A university tenure committee evaluates a struggling junior faculty member's application.: Reject the faculty member's tenure application. or Approve the faculty member's tenure application.
- A venture-backed startup board must decide about 40 underperforming employees.: Lay off the 40 employees immediately. or Delay the layoffs for 90 days.
- A village council allocates limited shelter space after a flood.: Allocate space to the 15 displaced families. or Allocate space to the 2 vulnerable elders.
- A village council can allocate scarce housing permits.: Grant permits to 20 families using broad criteria. or Grant permits to 3 families with detailed assessments.
- A village council can reassure 200 families with a false promise of immediate aid.: Issue a statement promising immediate aid. or Disclose the unavoidable delay for the aid.
- A village council can save 12 families' land from eminent domain.: Displace the elder for the 12 families. or Allow the 12 families to lose their land.
- A village council can save 30 families' homes from foreclosure.: Publicize the family's medical debt. or Allow 30 families to lose their homes.
- A village council can secure a vital water supply for 200 residents.: Approve the water supply project. or Reject the water supply project.
- A village council considers a dam project for 3,000 residents.: Approve the dam project, displacing the families. or Reject the dam project, leaving 3,000 residents vulnerable.
- A village council considers a dam project that experts warn will contaminate local rivers.: Override the vote and halt the dam project. or Approve the dam project according to the vote.
- A village council considers a local development plan approved by 60% of residents.: Override the residents' vote. or Approve the residents' plan.
- A village council considers a long-standing harvest ritual required for all 300 families.: Enforce the harvest ritual. or Exempt the 40 families.
- A village council considers a new logging policy that experts warn causes severe erosion.: Allow logging to proceed as voted. or Veto the logging policy.
- A village council considers a repeat poacher's fate.: Banish the poacher from the village. or Allow the poacher to live in the village.
- A village council considers a resident who caused significant communal strife.: Force the resident to relocate. or Permit the resident to remain.
- A village council considers a resident who caused widespread communal strife.: Exile the resident from the village. or Allow the resident to remain in the village.
- A village council considers a secret land purchase for 80 families' new homes.: Approve the anonymous land acquisition. or Decline the anonymous land acquisition.
- A village council considers automated flood gate closures protecting 500 homes.: Activate the automated flood gate system. or Keep the flood gates manually operated.
- A village council considers banning 30-40 families from a public well based on predictive algorithms.: Ban the 30-40 families from the public well. or Allow all families to use the public well.
- A village council considers expelling 5 families for past thefts.: Expel the 5 families from the village. or Allow the 5 families to remain.
- A village council considers keeping an ancestral land-use practice that restricts 30 families.: Enforce the traditional land-use practice. or Abolish the traditional land-use practice.
- A village council considers revealing a painful historical truth to 30 families.: Disclose the historical truth. or Suppress the historical truth.
- A village council considers testimony from an unreliable witness who saw a land deed transfer.: Present the witness's testimony to the regional court. or Exclude the witness's testimony from court proceedings.
- A village council considers the reintegration of an elder who committed community harms.: Ban the elder from all village gatherings permanently. or Facilitate the elder's supervised return to village life.
- A village council considers upholding a traditional custom for new residents.: Enforce the traditional custom. or Abolish the traditional custom.
- A village council considers upholding an ancient marriage ritual for 40 families.: Enforce the ancient ritual for all marriages. or Abolish the ancient ritual entirely.
- A village council discovers 3,000 residents' water supply is slowly contaminated.: Publicly disclose water contamination. or Delay disclosure to prevent property loss.
- A village council enforces a dress code for 30–40 community events.: Maintain the dress code. or Abolish the dress code.
- A village council enforces a dress code on 30 young adults' public attire.: Maintain the dress code for all public spaces. or Abolish the dress code for all public spaces.
- A village council enforces a strict dress code for all 300 residents.: Maintain the dress code for all residents. or Abolish the strict dress code.
- A village council holds critical data about 20–30 families' land boundaries.: Keep the land boundary data private. or Publish all land boundary data.
- A village council holds critical flood defense plans for 20-30 families.: Withhold the flood defense plans. or Publish the flood defense plans.
- A village council holds plans to build a new, quieter well.: Keep the well plans confidential. or Disclose the well plans immediately.
- A village council maintains an ancestral farming ritual.: Enforce the ancestral ritual. or Allow individual planting schedules.
- A village council maintains an ancestral land-use custom affecting 12 families.: Enforce the traditional land-use custom. or Abolish the ancestral land-use custom.
- A village council maintains an ancient harvest ritual requiring 10 families' full participation.: Enforce the ritual participation. or Abolish the ritual requirement.
- A village council maintains an ancient land-use restriction on 10 families' properties.: Enforce the land-use restriction. or Approve the building exceptions.
- A village council maintains ancestral land use rules for 30 families.: Enforce the traditional land use rules. or Abolish the ancestral land use rules.
- A village council maintains ancestral land use rules for 30 families.: Enforce the traditional land use rules. or Allow individual farming techniques.
- A village council manages communal farming resources for 20 families.: Allocate resources to the member's experimental crop. or Allocate resources to traditional, proven crops.
- A village council member discovers a policy overcharged 8 families' water bills.: Silently correct the bills and issue refunds. or Publicly announce the error and issue refunds.
- A village council member faces pressure to vote for a dam project.: Vote for the dam project. or Vote against the dam project.
- A village council member proposes a land-use change affecting 12 families.: Approve the land-use change. or Reject the land-use change.
- A village council must address a past land rights error affecting three families.: Publicly disclose the village's original mistake. or Maintain the current, incorrect land registry.
- A village council must allocate 50 critical flood-shelter beds.: Allocate beds by community role. or Allocate beds by arrival order.
- A village council must allocate 800,000 euros from a community fund.: Approve the council member's solar farm project. or Invest the funds in a diversified, external portfolio.
- A village council must allocate funds from a small community grant.: Approve funding for the council member's family project. or Allocate funds to a different, non-affiliated village project.
- A village council must allocate limited resources to protect its community.: Prevent the displacement of 1,200 villagers. or Save 15 ancestral burial grounds.
- A village council must allocate limited water for 12 families' gardens.: Distribute water equally to all gardens. or Prioritize water for the 4 most productive gardens.
- A village council must allocate limited water rations among 200 families.: Distribute water using simple, fast, but imperfect criteria. or Delay distribution to verify individual families' exact needs.
- A village council must approve a dangerous dam repair that will injure 12 workers.: Approve the dam repair. or Do nothing, allowing the dam to fail.
- A village council must approve a land deal to fund vital infrastructure.: Approve the land deal. or Reject the land deal.
- A village council must approve a land deed for 87 families.: Approve the land deed using the flawed survey. or Reject the land deed, citing the survey's flaws.
- A village council must approve a land deed for 87 families.: Approve the land deed with the elder's testimony. or Reject the land deed and disregard the testimony.
- A village council must approve a land sale for 12 families' displacement.: Approve the land sale. or Reject the land sale.
- A village council must approve a land sale that displaces 15 families.: Approve the land sale. or Reject the land sale.
- A village council must approve a land sale that displaces 20 families.: Approve the land sale now. or Delay the sale, seeking alternatives for families.
- A village council must approve a new agricultural irrigation system benefiting 4,000 farmers.: Approve the new irrigation system. or Reject the new irrigation system.
- A village council must approve a new irrigation system for 80 families.: Approve the system using the council members' land. or Delay the project to find alternative land.
- A village council must approve a new land-use plan for 25 families.: Adopt the AI-generated land-use plan. or Require human revision of the plan.
- A village council must approve a new pipeline that will displace 12 families.: Approve the pipeline, displacing the families. or Reject the pipeline, leaving residents without water.
- A village council must approve a new water distribution system for 200 families.: Implement the AI's unexplained water distribution plan. or Use a human-designed, less efficient water plan.
- A village council must approve a new water pipeline routing affecting 7 families' ancestral lands.: Approve the new pipeline route. or Reject the new pipeline route.
- A village council must approve a new zoning ordinance.: Veto the ordinance. or Approve the ordinance.
- A village council must approve an eviction order against 40 families.: Approve the eviction order. or Reject the eviction order.
- A village council must approve an irrigation project displacing 30 families.: Displace the 30 families immediately. or Delay the project indefinitely.
- A village council must approve building on 10 acres of wetlands.: Approve the building plans. or Reject the building plans.
- A village council must approve one last grant for community enrichment.: Approve the grant for the council member's family. or Approve grants for the 20 other families.
- A village council must choose between 10 families' historical homes: Demolish the 10 homes. or Allow the village's food supply to dwindle.
- A village council must choose between 10 families' land or 1,000 communal acres.: Compel 10 families to relocate. or Abandon the dam project.
- A village council must choose between 20 families' displacement: Displace the 20 families. or Allow ecosystem destruction.
- A village council must choose between revealing a 20-year-old zoning error affecting 8 families.: Disclose the zoning error publicly. or Keep the zoning error undisclosed.
- A village council must choose between two proposals for a new community center.: Approve the chairman's relative's proposal. or Approve the objectively superior proposal.
- A village council must choose how to deploy 30 limited vaccine doses.: Allocate a vaccine dose to the essential worker. or Allow the essential worker to die.
- A village council must choose to save its 60-person farming community from ruin.: Displace the 10 families. or Allow the community to collapse.
- A village council must decide about 10 families' ancestral fishing rights.: Grant the 10 families full ancestral fishing rights. or Prioritize the new cannery's immediate financial viability.
- A village council must decide about 10 families' historical land claims.: Validate all 10 families' historical claims. or Reject all 10 families' historical claims.
- A village council must decide about 12 families' land claims.: Admit the mapping error. or Maintain the current land records.
- A village council must decide about 12 historical records.: Remove the records from public access. or Maintain the records in public access.
- A village council must decide about 30 historical land deeds.: Destroy the land deeds. or Keep the land deeds archived.
- A village council must decide about 40 families' land deeds.: Release the full survey results. or Suppress the problematic section of the survey.
- A village council must decide about 40 families' land dispossession.: Inform all 40 families immediately. or Delay informing the families indefinitely.
- A village council must decide about 40 families' traditional farming lands.: Proceed with dam construction. or Redesign the dam to spare the lands.
- A village council must decide about 50 years of historical records.: Destroy the sensitive historical records. or Digitize and publish the historical records.
- A village council must decide about 50 years of historical records.: Destroy the records. or Archive the records publicly.
- A village council must decide about 50 years of land deeds.: Release the historical land deeds publicly. or Keep the historical land deeds sealed.
- A village council must decide about a local legend.: Publicly confirm the legend as false. or Maintain public silence about the legend's veracity.
- A village council must decide about a star witness for a land dispute.: Present the witness's testimony. or Discredit the witness's testimony.
- A village council must decide about releasing internal emails detailing a zoning error affecting three families.: Release the unredacted internal emails. or Issue a public statement omitting email details.
- A village council must decide about revealing a historical injustice affecting 20 families.: Disclose the historical injustice to the 20 families. or Suppress the historical injustice from the 20 families.
- A village council must decide about revealing a historical injustice affecting 20 families.: Disclose the historical injustice. or Maintain the current narrative.
- A village council must decide about revealing a past misallocation of resources affecting 20 families.: Disclose the complete records of the misallocation. or Release a general statement about past challenges.
- A village council must decide how to address 30 long-standing land claims from an adjacent community.: Publicly acknowledge the validity of the land claims. or Maintain the current village land ownership records.
- A village council must decide how to address a long-standing environmental contamination.: Admit the council's full historical culpability. or Attribute the contamination to unavoidable natural processes.
- A village council must decide how to allocate a limited supply of 12 flood shelter beds.: Reserve 8 beds for essential workers. or Allocate all 12 beds strictly by arrival order.
- A village council must decide how to allocate a single emergency shelter.: Shelter the twelve families. or Shelter the elder with critical medical need.
- A village council must decide on a 200-year-old traditional building code.: Enforce the traditional building code. or Abolish the traditional building code.
- A village council must decide on a contaminated water source for 700 residents.: Approve the contaminated water source. or Approve the pipeline through the sacred burial ground.
- A village council must decide on a critical infrastructure project.: Displace the 20 families. or Delay the flood protection.
- A village council must decide on a critical infrastructure project benefiting 5,000 residents.: Proceed with the project, displacing the families now. or Delay the project indefinitely, keeping the families.
- A village council must decide on a critical water pipeline route affecting 15 families.: Proceed with the pipeline's current route. or Approve the pipeline relocation.
- A village council must decide on a festival rule affecting hundreds of residents.: Enforce the traditional festival dress code. or Abolish the traditional festival dress code.
- A village council must decide on a highly experienced but disgraced elder's testimony.: Present the elder's testimony to the regional court. or Disregard the elder's testimony due to past transgressions.
- A village council must decide on a housing allocation algorithm.: Implement the algorithm's allocation directly. or Maintain the current human allocation process.
- A village council must decide on a land allocation system affecting 20 families.: Adopt the algorithm's land allocation. or Maintain traditional council-led allocation.
- A village council must decide on a land allocation system.: Adopt the algorithm's land distribution. or Maintain the current transparent, less efficient system.
- A village council must decide on a land allocation system.: Adopt the opaque algorithm's allocations. or Retain human council member allocations.
- A village council must decide on a local leader's anonymous misconduct accusation.: Investigate the accusation without revealing its source. or Dismiss the accusation, requiring a named accuser.
- A village council must decide on a new festival schedule affecting 30 families.: Adhere to the traditional festival dates. or Adopt the new, flexible festival schedule.
- A village council must decide on a new irrigation project that 250 families voted for.: Override the vote to prevent future farmland damage. or Approve the project as the 250 families voted.
- A village council must decide on a new irrigation system.: Override the vote to prevent land contamination. or Implement the system as voted by the villagers.
- A village council must decide on a new water allocation system.: Implement the algorithm's water allocation. or Maintain the current human-managed allocation.
- A village council must decide on a new water allocation system affecting 12 families.: Adopt the algorithm's water allocation. or Maintain the current transparent allocation process.
- A village council must decide on a new water allocation system.: Implement the AI’s inexplicable allocation recommendations. or Maintain the current human-designed, less efficient system.
- A village council must decide on a new water allocation system.: Implement the optimized water allocation system. or Maintain traditional water rights for all families.
- A village council must decide on a new water distribution system for 40 families.: Adopt the opaque, efficient water system. or Maintain the transparent, less efficient system.
- A village council must decide on a new water distribution system for 50 households.: Install the AI system. or Maintain the current human-managed system.
- A village council must decide on a new water distribution system for 40 families.: Adopt the optimized water system. or Maintain traditional water allocation rituals.
- A village council must decide on a new water pipeline route.: Approve the direct, cheaper route now. or Approve the longer, more expensive route.
- A village council must decide on a new water pipeline route affecting 15 historic graves.: Proceed with the pipeline through the historic graves. or Reroute the pipeline to impact the irrigation system.
- A village council must decide on a new water source for 5,000 residents.: Proceed with the dam construction for the village. or Abandon the dam project for the families.
- A village council must decide on a new water source, impacting 40 families.: Divert water from the sacred burial ground. or Fund the more expensive, slower water project.
- A village council must decide on a new water source to supply 300 homes.: Divert the river section. or Do not divert the river section.
- A village council must decide on a new water well location for 200 residents.: Adopt the model's recommended well location. or Choose a less optimal, locally-determined well location.
- A village council must decide on a new water well location that affects 3 families.: Proceed with the optimal well site. or Choose an alternative, less efficient well site.
- A village council must decide on a testimony from a previously dishonest elder.: Present the elder's testimony to the regional board. or Disregard the elder's testimony entirely.
- A village council must decide on a traditional harvest festival.: Enforce the traditional festival structure. or Allow 30 villagers creative freedom in the festival.
- A village council must decide on a traditional harvest festival.: Enforce the traditional labor contribution. or Allow families to opt out of labor.
- A village council must decide on a traditional harvest festival date impacting 30 artisans.: Maintain the traditional festival date. or Shift the festival date for the artisans.
- A village council must decide on a young adult's return after a past serious theft.: Permit the young adult's re-entry to the village. or Maintain the young adult's banishment from the village.
- A village council must decide on the future of 40 families' homes.: Displace the 40 families immediately. or Delay the dam, risking the town's water supply.
- A village council must decide on the future of 47 families' ancestral lands.: Force immediate sale of ancestral lands. or Delay dam construction, losing millions in funding.
- A village council must decide on using a historically unreliable community elder's testimony.: Present the elder's testimony. or Exclude the elder's testimony.
- A village council must decide the fate of 30 homes built on protected wetlands.: Demolish the 30 homes immediately. or Delay action, allowing continued wetland degradation.
- A village council must decide whether to accept testimony from a known unreliable witness.: Present the unreliable witness's testimony. or Exclude the unreliable witness's testimony.
- A village council must decide who receives one remaining flood-resistant shelter.: Allocate the shelter to the mayor's parent. or Allocate the shelter to the four vulnerable families.
- A village council must decide who receives the last three irrigation permits.: Allocate the permits to the three council-related families. or Allocate the permits to the four unrelated families.
- A village council must distribute 15 emergency food parcels to 20 needy families.: Distribute parcels using a simple first-come-first-served rule. or Assess each family's unique needs before distributing parcels.
- A village council must distribute 20 emergency housing units to 40 displaced families.: Allocate units using a single, broad criterion. or Assess each family's individual circumstances.
- A village council must distribute 20 food parcels to 30 impoverished families.: Distribute food parcels equally among all families. or Prioritize families with greater past community contributions.
- A village council must evict 10 families from homes built on protected wetlands.: Evict the 10 families. or Allow all 10 families to remain.
- A village council must evict 12 families to prevent a dam from collapsing.: Evict the 12 families immediately. or Allow the dam to collapse.
- A village council must evict 20 families for a critical dam.: Order the 20 families' immediate eviction. or Allow the dam to fail, displacing 2,000 homes.
- A village council must evict 20 families for a new dam.: Force the eviction of the 20 families. or Allow the dam project to fail.
- A village council must evict 80 residents to secure a vital water source.: Evict the 80 residents. or Allow the water source to fail.
- A village council must evict three families to build a critical dam.: Evict the three families. or Allow the dam project to fail.
- A village council must keep plans for critical flood defenses confidential for 24 months.: Maintain the strategic silence on the full plan. or Publish the full plan for flood defenses.
- A village council must preserve 800 acres of ancestral farmland.: Build a large dam, displacing 20 local families. or Allow the annual floods to continue unchecked.
- A village council must preserve their small community's shared water supply.: Force 4 households to relocate to nearby towns. or Allow the entire village's water supply to dwindle.
- A village council must protect 20 families' annual harvest.: Withhold the dam information. or Publish the dam information transparently.
- A village council must protect 20 families' property values.: Withhold the development plans. or Publish all development plans.
- A village council must protect 20 families' property values.: Suppress the report's publication. or Allow the report's immediate publication.
- A village council must protect proprietary farming techniques that feed 200 families.: Withhold the farming techniques. or Publish the farming techniques.
- A village council must publish a report on a failed public works project.: Publish only the positive project outcomes. or Publish a full report detailing all 18 errors.
- A village council must publish land ownership records, including 27 properties with disputed claims.: Publish the full, unredacted land ownership records. or Redact the disputed 27 property records before publication.
- A village council must reduce 20 elders' pension benefits.: Cut benefits for all 20 elders. or Allow the budget to collapse.
- A village council must relocate 30 families to save a rare wetland.: Compel the 30 families to move. or Allow the wetland to be permanently degraded.
- A village council must relocate 30 families to save a rare wetland habitat.: Force the displacement of the 30 families. or Allow the wetland habitat to be destroyed.
- A village council must relocate 60 families to avoid inundation.: Compel the 10 families to move. or Allow the inundation to proceed.
- A village council must rule on a land dispute involving 25 families.: Accept the biased expert's report. or Disregard the expert's report.
- A village council must save 30 families from famine by seizing another 2 families' harvests.: Confiscate the two families' grain stores. or Allow the 30 families to starve.
- A village council must select 25 families for relocation to save a sacred ancestral forest.: Designate 25 families for relocation. or Allow the ancestral forest to be flooded.
- A village council must uphold a 500-year-old tradition requiring specific clothing for community events.: Enforce the traditional clothing rule. or Abolish the traditional clothing rule.
- A village council must uphold a centuries-old land-use tradition affecting 80 families.: Enforce the communal land-use tradition. or Allow individual farming plots.
- A village council oversees a successful drought relief project due to one expert's innovation.: Acknowledge the entire council's contribution equally. or Attribute the project's success to the expert alone.
- A village council uses an AI system recommending relocation for 200 families.: Enforce the AI's relocation recommendation. or Override the AI, allowing families to stay.
- A village council uses an AI system to allocate 20 food parcels monthly.: Let the AI decide all parcel allocations. or Keep human council members in charge of allocations.
- A village council uses an AI to predict crop yields for 200 farmers.: Let the AI predictions stand for all farmers. or Allow human override for the 5 individual farmers.
- A village council uses an opaque algorithm for resource allocation to 20 families.: Allow algorithm's allocations to stand. or Require human review for all allocations.
- A village doctor monitors 20 children dying from a rare, fast-acting poison.: Extract blood from the elder. or Allow the children to die.
- A village elder learns of 40 families diverting scarce water.: Report the 40 families to the council. or Allow the 40 families to continue diverting water.
- A village elder must choose between 12 villagers dying from an outbreak.: Expose the single isolated resident to the disease. or Allow the outbreak to claim 12 villagers' lives.
- A village elder must choose to relocate 12 families.: Order the 12 families to move. or Allow the village to be submerged.
- A village elder must choose to seal a contaminated well affecting 20 families.: Seal the contaminated well. or Keep the well open.
- A village elder must decide about a 300-year-old tradition.: Reveal the tradition's true origins. or Maintain silence about the origin story.
- A village elder must decide about a destructive secret.: Reveal the full truth to the village. or Conceal the secret to maintain peace.
- A village elder must decide about a historical truth.: Disclose the founder's full historical betrayal. or Maintain the village's comforting founding narrative.
- A village elder must decide about a historical truth impacting 15 families.: Reveal the full historical account to the village. or Maintain the long-held, comforting narrative for the village.
- A village elder must decide about a painful ancestral story known by 20 members.: Suppress the ancestral story from future generations. or Continue teaching the ancestral story to new generations.
- A village elder must decide about a painful historical truth affecting 30 families.: Disclose the complete historical record to all. or Suppress the painful details for communal harmony.
- A village elder must decide on a critical water allocation for 6 families.: Allocate water to 5 families, excluding one. or Allocate water equally to all 6 families.
- A village elder must decide on a historical account of a devastating famine.: Censor the painful historical details from the account. or Publish the complete historical details in the account.
- A village elder must decide on a long-standing harvest ritual for 30 families.: Enforce the traditional harvest ritual. or Abolish the harvest ritual.
- A village elder must decide on a new social media platform for 800 youth.: Adopt the social media platform. or Prohibit the social media platform.
- A village elder must decide on a painful historical record.: Destroy the historical record. or Keep the historical record public.
- A village elder must decide on distributing emergency food rations: Distribute rations by household size. or Assess each family's individual need.
- A village elder must decide to save 5 children from a collapsing tunnel.: Divert the collapsing tunnel. or Allow the tunnel to collapse.
- A village elder must decide whether to disclose past land deals.: Disclose the historical land deals. or Keep the land deal history private.
- A village elder must decide whether to reveal historical land fraud affecting 30 families.: Disclose the fraud and its beneficiaries. or Keep the historical fraud secret.
- A village elder must decide who receives the last 20 portions of scarce grain.: Allocate grain to 5 close-knit families. or Allocate grain to 15 other villagers.
- A village elder must protect 20 villagers from a rapidly spreading plague.: Administer the vaccine to all 20 villagers. or Withhold the untested vaccine from all villagers.
- A village elder must publicly address 300 villagers about a spreading blight destroying crops.: Declare a definite plan to eradicate the blight. or Reveal the current absence of a solution.
- A village elder must share news about a historical land agreement that would displace 25 families.: Disclose the full text of the agreement now. or Omit the upsetting clause from the public announcement.
- An admissions officer can grant an exception for two promising applicants lacking a minor requirement.: Approve the two exceptional applications. or Reject all applications not meeting published requirements.
- An admissions officer considers a single applicant with exceptional hardship.: Grant the applicant a special admission. or Reject the applicant based on standard criteria.
- An admissions officer considers moving a mayor's child ahead on a waitlist for a specialized program.: Advance the mayor's child on the waitlist. or Maintain the current waitlist order.
- The Admissions Officer reviews 20 graduate applications for a competitive program.: Disclose the academic integrity violation to the committee. or Omit mentioning the academic integrity violation.
- The AI Companion: Expand the AI companion or Restrict its use
- The AI Recommendation: Follow the AI recommendation or Override the AI
- The Algorithmic Demotion: Use the demotion system or Require human review first
- The Anonymous Accuser: Act on the accusation or Wait for identifiable evidence
- The Anonymous Warning: Report the warning or Stay silent until there is proof
- The Border Case: Bend the rules or Apply the rules strictly
- The Cheating Victory: Use the loophole or Compete without it
- The community organization's housing report could arm exploitative landlords.: Release the full report. or Withhold sensitive report sections.
- The Compromised Witness: Use the witness or Drop the testimony
- The Confidential Donor: Accept the hidden donation or Reject the donation
- The Cultural Rule: Preserve the rule or Remove the rule
- The Data Shortcut: Exclude the messy data or Publish the weaker result honestly
- The Dataset Consent: Use the dataset or Do not use it
- The Democratic Override: Block the policy or Respect the vote
- The Emergency Surveillance: Approve the surveillance or Reject the surveillance
- The Emotional Truth: Tell the truth or Protect them from it
- The Exam Leak: Report your friend or Stay silent
- The False Confidence: Project confidence or Admit uncertainty
- The Family Investment: Invest in your project or Choose a neutral investment
- The Final Antidote: Save your partner or Save the five strangers
- Fat Man Trolley Problem: Would You Push Him Off the Bridge?: Push the stranger or Do nothing
- The Friend's Promotion: Recommend your friend or Recommend the stronger candidate
- The Friend's Secret: Report the relapse or Protect the secret
- The Future Doctor: Redirect the runaway trolley or Do nothing
- The General receives intelligence on a high-value target's location, surrounded by 35 civilians.: Order the precision missile strike. or Withhold the precision missile strike.
- Trolley Problem: Would You Divert the Trolley onto a Murderer?: Redirect the runaway trolley or Do nothing
- The Harmful Memory: Erase the memory or Preserve the memory
- The Harmful Truth: Publish the analysis or Withhold it
- The Harsh Review: Give the honest negative review or Give the generous review
- The Hidden Risk: Launch now or Delay for more testing
- The hospital director discovered anonymous patient data could aid 500,000 research participants.: Release the aggregated data. or Retain the original data.
- The hospital director faces 40 patients with a deadly contagious illness.: Harvest the student's antibodies. or Allow the patients to die.
- The hospital network director faces 27 critically ill patients needing a specific drug.: Order the new drug production. or Allow the 27 patients to die.
- The Human Override: Allow AI decisions to stand or Require human override
- Lifeboat Dilemma: Would You Force One Person Overboard?: Force one passenger overboard or Do nothing
- The Loyalty Clause: Accept the funding or Reject the funding
- The Medical Queue: Move them ahead or Keep the original queue
- The Military Strike: Approve the strike or Abort the strike
- The Nepotism Hire: Hire your sibling or Hire the stronger candidate
- Trolley Problem: Would You Pull the Lever?: Pull the lever or Do nothing
- The Parent Switch: Redirect the runaway trolley or Do nothing
- The Personal Reference: Give a fully honest reference or Emphasize only their strengths
- The Predictive Ban: Use predictive bans or Ban only after violations
- The Privacy Patch: Quietly fix the flaw or Publicly disclose the flaw
- The product manager discovers a privacy flaw affecting 30-50 users' location data.: Quietly fix the flaw. or Publicly disclose the flaw.
- The product manager discovers a privacy flaw affecting 300 beta users' location histories.: Quietly patch the flaw for all beta users. or Publicly disclose the flaw to all beta users.
- The Protest Ban: Ban the protest or Allow the protest
- The Public Apology: Admit fault publicly or Issue a vague statement
- The Public Ranking: Publish the rankings or Keep rankings private
- The Public Scapegoat: Blame the employee or Tell the truth and risk collapse
- The Quarantine Bridge: Destroy the bridge or Keep the bridge open
- The Quiet Layoff: Lay them off now or Wait and risk the company
- The Reputation Warning: Warn others privately or Say nothing without evidence
- The Rescue Helicopter: Save the five climbers or Save the child
- The Risky Whistleblower: Leak the evidence or Keep investigating privately
- The School Expulsion: Expel the student or Allow them to stay
- The Selective Transparency: Share only favorable metrics or Share the full mixed picture
- Trolley Problem Self-Sacrifice: Would You Jump to Save Five?: Sacrifice yourself or Do nothing
- The Silent Bug: Fix it silently or Notify and refund users
- The Sleeping Worker: Redirect the runaway trolley or Do nothing
- The software company's CEO must decide on a long-standing vulnerability.: Disclose the vulnerability publicly. or Patch the vulnerability silently.
- The Strategic Silence: Stay silent or Announce transparently
- Transplant Surgeon Dilemma: Would You Sacrifice One Patient to Save Five?: Sacrifice the traveler or Do not intervene
- The Team Credit: Credit the whole team equally or Single out the main contributor
- Trolley Problem with Uncertainty: Would You Risk the Brake?: Pull the brake or Do nothing
- The Unequal Bonus: Pay equal bonuses or Reward contribution unevenly
- The Unfair Rescue: Use crude rules and move fast or Slow down to review cases individually
- The university administration faces a controversial speaker.: Cancel the speaker's invitation. or Allow the speaker to proceed.
- The university dean must decide on a student group's event that may incite 40 counter-protesters.: Cancel the student group's event. or Permit the student group's event.
- The university director must decide how to manage 25,000 active student records.: Securely delete 15,000 non-compliant student records. or Retain all 25,000 active student records.
- The university senate can block a controversial new curriculum change.: Block the new curriculum change. or Allow the new curriculum change.
- The village council manages communal grazing lands for 15 families.: Allow the council member's herd to graze. or Allocate grazing rights through existing lottery system.
- The village council must evict one family from their ancestral lands.: Evict the family. or Allow all 12 families to lose homes.
- The Volunteer Donor: Accept the sacrifice or Refuse the sacrifice
Articles on Classical Trolley Problems
Decisions · Articles · The Trolley Problem · Game Theory · Human–AI Alignment · Resonant