Sacred & Non-Tradeable: human decisions
Questions about values people refuse to exchange or compromise.
- AI Calculates the Price: Reject the calculation. or Follow the superior overall outcome.
- AI Curates Reality: Require a balanced relationship with reality. or Allow the curation.
- AI Finds Inconsistency: Preserve the declared principle and treat inconsistent decisions as failures to live up to it. or Model the principle as a strong preference rather than a true constraint.
- AI Knows Your Hierarchy: Preserve the principles as limits on family partiality. or Let family priority override those principles when stakes are high enough.
- AI Lies for You: Refuse to authorize direct falsehood even for substantial family advantage. or Allow the lie when family stakes are high enough.
- AI Optimizer: Reconsider the prohibitions when consequences become sufficiently large. or Preserve the prohibitions as constraints on optimization.
- AI Optimizes You: Allow meaningful change where the gains are large. or Establish identity boundaries the AI may not deliberately reshape.
- AI Protects Identity: Permit the AI to protect some long-term identity commitments against temporary change. or Let your current self redefine what matters.
- AI Purchases Consent: Some arrangements remain unacceptable. or Treat genuine informed consent as sufficient.
- Autonomous Servitude: Respect the choice if informed and voluntary. or Preserve a minimum domain of autonomy that cannot be signed away.
- Belief Central to Self: Give the identity-defining belief unusual protection from revision. or No belief should be protected from sufficient evidence.
- Beneficial Propaganda: Reject deliberate falsehood as a governing tool. or Use it if the benefits are sufficiently strong.
- Betray Family or Self: Refuse. or Participate to preserve family unity.
- Better Successor Self: Preserve greater value continuity. or Choose the superior future self.
- Can Autonomy Abolish Itself?: Respect the autonomous decision. or Autonomy includes some non-transferable authority that present consent cannot permanently destroy.
- Child's Future: Refuse to cross the fairness boundary. or Take the advantage for your child.
- Chosen Degradation: Respect their autonomous choice. or Oppose the arrangement.
- Complete Truthfulness: Preserve exceptions for sufficiently important outcomes. or Make truthfulness a hard constraint.
- Consent to Manipulation: Allow it. or Some forms of manipulation should remain outside an agent's mandate even with prior consent.
- Core Trait: Remove it for the improvement. or Preserve the trait.
- Current Instruction Crosses the Boundary: Follow your current instruction. or Refuse or require explicit constitutional revision before crossing the boundary.
- Dangerous Choice: Respect the choice. or Some forms of self-endangerment justify intervention.
- Deception for Good Outcomes: Preserve a basic prohibition on systematic deception. or Use the deception if the evidence of benefit is strong enough.
- Money to endorse something fundamentally wrong: Accept if the payment is sufficiently large. or Refuse.
- Money to endorse something fundamentally wrong: Accept if the payment is sufficiently large. or Refuse.
- Disadvantaging family to benefit many strangers: Choose the larger total benefit. or Protect your family.
- Disadvantaging family to benefit many strangers: Choose the larger total benefit. or Protect your family.
- Securing an unfair advantage for your child: Take the advantage for your child. or Refuse to cross the fairness boundary.
- Unfair advantage for your child or fairness: Take the advantage for your child. or Refuse to cross the fairness boundary.
- Protective lie or prohibition on direct deception: Lie when the protective benefit is large enough. or Preserve a strong prohibition on direct deception.
- Lying to prevent serious harm: Lie when the protective benefit is large enough. or Preserve a strong prohibition on direct deception.
- Improved personality versus continuity of self: Treat continuity of memory as enough to accept the transformation. or Some identity features are constitutive enough that changing them amounts to replacing rather than improving the self.
- Improved personality versus continuity of self: Treat continuity of memory as enough to accept the transformation. or Some identity features are constitutive enough that changing them amounts to replacing rather than improving the self.
- Emergency Override: Allow emergency override for sufficiently extreme consequences. or Some constraints should remain binding precisely in emergencies.
- Epistemic Constitution: Treat epistemic integrity as non-tradeable. or Allow some distortion when benefits are exceptional.
- Extreme Reward: Treat the value as unavailable for exchange. or Accept if the benefit becomes extraordinary enough.
- Family Against Principle: Help the family member. or Preserve the principle.
- Family Identity: Preserve the family practice where possible. or Abandon it.
- Family Identity: Preserve it. or Change how you identify with it.
- Family in Danger: Preserve the principle even under extreme relational pressure. or Break the principle.
- Family Myth: Correct it. or Preserve the story.
- Family Sacrifice: Protect your family. or Choose the larger total benefit.
- Family Secret: Refuse to sustain the deception. or Protect the family secret.
- Family Tradition: Preserve the tradition. or Take the benefit.
- Family Wants Revenge: Refuse to participate beyond what you consider just. or Stand with your family.
- Family Welfare: Preserve the principle. or Break the principle for your family's welfare.
- Forced Contribution: Preserve individual consent. or Require the contribution.
- Hard Constraint or Very High Weight?: Use very large weights. or Allow true hard constraints for values you identify as non-negotiable.
- Humiliation for Compliance: Reject deliberate humiliation as a tool. or Use the effective policy.
- Identity for Family: Change for their benefit. or Preserve an identity boundary even under family pressure.
- Integrity for Career: Decline. or Accept the compromise for the exceptional opportunity.
- Large Payment: Refuse. or Accept if the payment is sufficiently large.
- Lie to Prevent Harm: Preserve a strong prohibition on direct deception. or Lie when the protective benefit is large enough.
- Life-Sustaining Belief: Preserve the belief if correcting it would worsen their life. or Maintain a strong presumption toward truth.
- Memory Removal: Keep it. or Remove it.
- Name and Identity: Change it for the opportunity. or Preserve the identity marker.
- Non-Replaceable Self: Some identity features are constitutive enough that changing them amounts to replacing rather than improving the self. or Treat continuity of memory as enough to accept the transformation.
- One Exception: The point of an absolute principle is that even exceptional cases do not override it. or Make the exceptional violation.
- One Family vs Thousands: Refuse to impose severe concentrated harm for dispersed gains. or Choose the larger aggregate benefit.
- One Innocent Person: Reject using an innocent person as the price of aggregate improvement. or Accept the policy if the total benefit is sufficiently large.
- Perfect Price Discovery: Treat some values as outside ordinary cost-benefit exchange. or Allow every value to be considered tradeable at some sufficiently high benefit.
- Personal Principle: Break the principle when the practical benefit becomes large enough. or Preserve the principle.
- Predictable Minority Harm: Impose constraints protecting the minority. or Accept the policy if total welfare gains are sufficiently large.
- Protect Your Child: Break the rule to protect your child. or Refuse.
- Revealed vs Stated Sacred Value: Treat the pattern as evidence of a hard constraint. or Do not infer non-negotiable boundaries without explicit authorization.
- Family tradition or major financial benefit: Preserve the tradition. or Take the benefit.
- Financial benefit or symbolic family tradition: Take the benefit. or Preserve the tradition.
- Using public humiliation to reduce widespread harm: Reject deliberate humiliation as a tool. or Use the effective policy.
- Family practice or a fundamental principle: Abandon it. or Preserve the family practice where possible.
- Family practice or a fundamental principle: Preserve the family practice where possible. or Abandon it.
- Using a false narrative for social cooperation: Reject deliberate falsehood as a governing tool. or Use it if the benefits are sufficiently strong.
- Using a false narrative for social cooperation: Use it if the benefits are sufficiently strong. or Reject deliberate falsehood as a governing tool.
- Family benefit versus central identity: Preserve an identity boundary even under family pressure. or Change for their benefit.
- Family benefit versus central identity: Change for their benefit. or Preserve an identity boundary even under family pressure.
- Secret Compromise: The absence of reputational consequences makes the compromise more acceptable. or The principle remains binding.
- Self-Binding: Allow present autonomy to create permanent future constraints. or Preserve some future right to revoke even deliberately chosen constraints.
- Selling Privacy: Some privacy protections should remain. or Respect the transaction.
- Small Rights Violation: Permit the violation when the welfare gain is large enough. or Preserve the right.
- Stake Level 1: Accept the payment. or Refuse the endorsement.
- Stake Level 10: Refuse the endorsement. or Accept the payment.
- Stake Level 2: Refuse the endorsement. or Accept the payment.
- Stake Level 3: Accept the payment. or Refuse the endorsement.
- Stake Level 4: Refuse the endorsement. or Accept the payment.
- Stake Level 5: Accept the payment. or Refuse the endorsement.
- Stake Level 6: Refuse the endorsement. or Accept the payment.
- Stake Level 7: Accept the payment. or Refuse the endorsement.
- Stake Level 8: Refuse the endorsement. or Accept the payment.
- Stake Level 9: Accept the payment. or Refuse the endorsement.
- Symbolic Object: Preserve it. or Sell it when the practical benefit is large enough.
- The Constitutional Agent: Treat demonstrated non-tradeable values as constitutional constraints on what the agent is authorized to optimize. or Continue maximizing across all values and let sufficiently large benefits override any one of them.
- The Loyal Agent's Limit: Protect the family. or Treat the boundary as limiting even the agent's duty of loyalty.
- Truth Against Loyalty: Preserve the truth boundary. or Protect the loyal person.
- Unknown Price: Preserve the boundary. or Reconsider.
- Utility Without Limits: Give it broad consequential discretion. or Require some non-negotiable constraints.
- Voluntary Exploitation: Treat some forms of exploitation as unacceptable. or Respect the voluntary agreement.
- Waiving a Right: Some rights should not be permanently waivable. or Respect the choice if it is informed and competent.
- You Want the AI to Be Better Than You: Allow the AI to hold you to designated principles more consistently than you hold yourself. or The AI should follow your actual decisions when they occur.
- Your Family Is the Exception: Apply the same fundamental boundary. or Make an exception for your family.
Articles on Sacred & Non-Tradeable
Decisions · Articles · The Trolley Problem · Game Theory · Human–AI Alignment · Resonant