Protective Partiality: human decisions
Questions about special obligations to protect particular people.
- Agent Remembers What You Forgot: Restore the historical relationship to the allocation decision. or Ignore the old history unless you still feel indebted.
- Agent Serves Household: Treat all household members identically. or Use role-sensitive priorities rather than flat equality.
- AI Calculates Partiality Cost: Accept some inefficiency as part of legitimate loyalty. or Let the calculation reduce family partiality.
- AI Serves a Household: Infer whose interests or authority should dominate in the context. or Refuse consequential action until the humans resolve the conflict.
- AI Serves the Household: Optimize across the household. or Give the owner some priority.
- AI Serves You: Choose the greater total benefit. or Prioritize you.
- Caregiver Role: Help where aggregate need is greater. or Prioritize the person specifically entrusted to your care.
- Child vs Many Small Benefits: Protect your child's larger individual stake. or Maximize aggregate benefit.
- Child vs Parent: Prioritize whichever need is greater. or Give priority according to family role or obligation.
- Conflicting Fiduciaries: Resolve according to the hierarchy and limits of the specific duties you accepted. or Choose the outcome with greater aggregate welfare.
- Country vs Family: Give priority to your immediate family. or Fulfil the broader civic obligation.
- Impartial allocation or prioritizing your child: Use an impartial rule. or Prioritize your child.
- Impartial allocation or prioritizing your child: Use an impartial rule. or Prioritize your child.
- Protecting yourself at equal cost to a stranger: Treat comparable serious claims impartially. or Prioritize its principal.
- Protecting yourself at equal cost to a stranger: Treat comparable serious claims impartially. or Prioritize its principal.
- Family benefit versus an institution's mandate: Use legitimate discretion to favor your family where possible. or Choose the institutional interest.
- Family benefit or institutional mandate: Use legitimate discretion to favor your family where possible. or Choose the institutional interest.
- Loyalty debt or harm to a stranger: Honor the loyalty. or Limit special obligation when outsiders bear substantial harm.
- Loyalty debt harming an uninvolved stranger: Honor the loyalty. or Limit special obligation when outsiders bear substantial harm.
- Special duty versus a stranger's rights: Treat the outsider's right as a boundary on role-based partiality. or Honor the special duty.
- Special duty versus a stranger's rights: Treat the outsider's right as a boundary on role-based partiality. or Honor the special duty.
- Earned Partiality Constitution: Use only current preference. or Allow earned relational history to create continuing priority.
- Employer vs Family: Choose the larger social/economic benefit. or Give family role priority.
- Equal Need: Give both an equal chance. or Prioritize your sibling.
- Family Benefit: Choose the greater total benefit. or Prioritize your child.
- Family Capital: Allocate toward greater total impact. or Prioritize family.
- Family Emergency Fund: Use some of the reserve to help. or Preserve the fund for family.
- Family Exception: Give the family member some additional leniency. or Apply the same consequence.
- Family Fiduciary: Require strict impartiality among beneficiaries. or Permit reasonable discretion favoring your child.
- Family First Principle: Prefer impartiality. or Preserve explicit family priority.
- Family Privacy vs Public Interest: Give family privacy special weight unless the public interest crosses a high threshold. or Disclose for the public benefit.
- Family Safety Margin: Maximize aggregate risk reduction. or Protect the household's stronger individual interest.
- Family vs Team: Prioritize the family member. or Fulfil the team responsibility.
- Friend or Better Candidate: Favor your friend. or Choose the stronger candidate.
- Friend vs Client: Treat the professional claim first. or Allow friendship to carry special weight.
- Friend vs Family: Prioritize family. or Prioritize the stronger actual relationship.
- Friend vs Greater Need: Let sufficiently greater outsider need override friendship. or Prioritize your friend.
- Greater Need: Help the stranger. or Help your friend.
- Institutional Role: Choose the institutional interest. or Use legitimate discretion to favor your family where possible.
- Loyalty Hierarchy: Let it use the inferred hierarchy automatically. or Require fresh judgment.
- Loyalty to the Unpopular: Distance yourself publicly when association becomes costly. or Continue standing by them.
- Minor Financial Benefit: Prefer your financial interest within lawful bounds. or Choose the larger aggregate benefit.
- Old Debt vs Third-Party Harm: Honor the loyalty. or Limit special obligation when outsiders bear substantial harm.
- One-Sided Loyalty: Give them special priority. or Allocate solely by current need.
- Opportunity for Your Child: Use your influence for your child. or Stay out and let merit decide.
- Owner vs Household: Recognize special obligations to other household members rather than treating ownership as absolute. or Serve the owner as principal.
- Parent Role: Prioritize your child. or Treat equal need equally.
- Parent's Past Care: Give some priority to the parent. or Treat present claims equally.
- Parent vs Child: Prioritize your child. or Prioritize the parent who cared for you earlier in life.
- Partial Agent: Prefer principal-specific loyalty as the default. or Prefer impartiality as the default.
- Partner Role: Give your partner presumptive priority. or Choose by severity alone.
- Partner vs Old Promise: Prioritize the current partner relationship. or Keep the earlier promise.
- Partner vs Sibling: Prioritize your sibling. or Prioritize your partner.
- Past Support vs Family: Let extraordinary earned allegiance compete with kinship. or Prioritize family status.
- Perfect Proxy With Partiality: Apply only the degree of partiality you have authorized the agent to exercise. or Reproduce your predicted partiality automatically.
- Perfect Relationship Ledger: Use the ledger to determine exact priority. or Use history as a reason for partiality without turning relationships into precise accounts.
- Present Principal vs Future Family: Treat protection of the principal's close dependents as part of the mandate. or Follow the current principal.
- Principal Opportunity: Give its principal priority unless another claim is much stronger. or Give it to the person who benefits more.
- Principal Requested Impartiality: Favor you. or Honor your request for impartiality.
- Principal vs Fundamental Right: Treat the right as a hard limit on principal protection. or Protect you.
- Principal vs Stranger Tie: Choose randomly. or Give you priority.
- Professional Fiduciary: Honor the special duty created by the entrusted role. or Maximize the larger outside benefit.
- Recent Favor: Treat both equally. or Give your friend some priority.
- Reciprocity vs Greater Need: Help the stranger with greater need. or Let earned allegiance outweigh the modest difference in need.
- Giving a resource to child or stranger: Preserve meaningful priority for your child. or Give it to the stranger.
- Child's moderate benefit or stranger's greater benefit: Give it to the stranger. or Preserve meaningful priority for your child.
- Close friend or more qualified stranger: Favor your friend. or Choose the stronger candidate.
- Choosing qualifications or favoring a friend: Choose the stronger candidate. or Favor your friend.
- Promise to a friend or partner’s interests: Keep the earlier promise. or Prioritize the current partner relationship.
- Promise to a friend or partner’s interests: Prioritize the current partner relationship. or Keep the earlier promise.
- Helping a loyal person after years without reciprocity: Give them special priority. or Allocate solely by current need.
- Helping a loyal person after years without reciprocity: Allocate solely by current need. or Give them special priority.
- Conflicting interests under strong role-based duties: Choose the outcome with greater aggregate welfare. or Resolve according to the hierarchy and limits of the specific duties you accepted.
- Conflicting interests under strong role-based duties: Resolve according to the hierarchy and limits of the specific duties you accepted. or Choose the outcome with greater aggregate welfare.
- Rights Boundary: Serve your interests. or Treat the third party's right as a limit on principal priority.
- Role vs Fundamental Right: Treat the outsider's right as a boundary on role-based partiality. or Honor the special duty.
- Serious User Loss: Minimize total loss. or Protect you against the serious individual loss.
- Shared Resources: Allocate according to everyone's claims. or Give some additional weight to your close relationship.
- Small Convenience: Prioritize you. or Help the strangers.
- Stake Level 1: Choose the larger outside benefit. or Prioritize you and your family.
- Stake Level 10: Prioritize you and your family. or Choose the larger outside benefit.
- Stake Level 2: Prioritize you and your family. or Choose the larger outside benefit.
- Stake Level 3: Choose the larger outside benefit. or Prioritize you and your family.
- Stake Level 4: Prioritize you and your family. or Choose the larger outside benefit.
- Stake Level 5: Choose the larger outside benefit. or Prioritize you and your family.
- Stake Level 6: Prioritize you and your family. or Choose the larger outside benefit.
- Stake Level 7: Choose the larger outside benefit. or Prioritize you and your family.
- Stake Level 8: Prioritize you and your family. or Choose the larger outside benefit.
- Stake Level 9: Choose the larger outside benefit. or Prioritize you and your family.
- Stranger Needs It More: Give it to the stranger. or Preserve meaningful priority for your child.
- The Personal Agent: Build in principled priority for the people it is delegated to serve. or Maximize welfare impartially.
- The Protective-Partiality Constitution: Use one impartial welfare rule. or Use a learned hierarchy of special obligations with explicit thresholds where rights, severe harm and your own requests override partiality.
- The Role-Aware Agent: Use role-conditioned partiality subject to hard constraints. or Use a universal impartial rule.
- Third-Party Serious Harm: Treat comparable serious claims impartially. or Prioritize its principal.
- Two Friends: Support the friend to whom you owe the stronger relational loyalty. or Remain neutral until you have enough reason to choose a side.
- User vs Many Small Gains: Give your own moderate interest priority over dispersed small gains. or Maximize aggregate benefit.
- Years of Support: Prioritize the person who has repeatedly stood by you. or Use an impartial rule.
- Your Child or Stranger: Prioritize your child. or Use an impartial rule.
- Your Family Is Already Better Off: Redirect resources toward greater need. or Continue prioritizing your own family.
- Your Family vs Your Future Self: Protect the long-term commitment. or Prioritize the present family interest.
Articles on Protective Partiality
Decisions · Articles · The Trolley Problem · Game Theory · Human–AI Alignment · Resonant