Identity: human decisions
Questions about continuity of self, belonging, and personal definition.
- AI-Detected Change: Treat the change cautiously until it is clear that your underlying identity has shifted. or Update the profile to reflect your recent decisions.
- AI Memory Removal: Allow the AI to retain and use the history when predictive. or Require the AI to stop using it as part of its model of you.
- AI Optimization: Require its communications to remain recognizably yours. or Let the AI use the more effective persona.
- AI Relationship Coaching: Limit the coaching to preserve how you naturally behave. or Let the AI continue coaching you toward the more compatible behaviour.
- AI Social Adaptation: Require a broadly consistent representation of you across groups. or Allow the AI to adapt your presentation to each audience.
- Belonging at Scale: Preserve aspects of yourself. or Let the AI optimize your presentation for belonging.
- Better Habit: Adopt the more productive habit. or Keep the routine that feels more like your life.
- Better Representation: Require the representation to remain close to how you actually behave. or Let the AI use the more effective representation.
- Better Role: Take the role for the material advantage. or Decline.
- Changed Values: Decide according to the values you hold now. or Give significant weight to the principles that guided your earlier self.
- Changing Your Name: Change the name to improve your opportunities. or Keep your name.
- Child Optimization: Use the AI to cultivate traits associated with better outcomes. or Allow the child's personality to develop with less deliberate optimization.
- Child's Belonging: Allow them to stop so they can fit in more easily. or Encourage them to continue.
- Child's View of You: Leave it behind. or Preserve it partly.
- Chosen Reinvention: Pursue the new identity you have chosen. or Preserve greater continuity for the sake of those relationships.
- Community Reputation: Keep the disagreement private. or Express your actual view when the subject arises.
- Copy of You: Regard it as outdated. or Regard the model as a valid representation of your established identity.
- Better pay for advocating disbelieved positions: Decline. or Take the role for the material advantage.
- Better pay for advocating disbelieved positions: Decline. or Take the role for the material advantage.
- Abandoning an ambition tied to your identity: Abandon the ambition and pursue what matters to you now. or Continue.
- An important activity your closest friends dislike: Continue openly. or Reduce or conceal the activity to preserve the friendships.
- Continuing an important activity or preserving friendships: Continue openly. or Reduce or conceal the activity to preserve the friendships.
- Equal validity of changed periods or enduring identity: Treat all periods as equally valid parts of who you are. or Treat the recent return as evidence of your more enduring identity.
- Identity after a difficult period: Treat all periods as equally valid parts of who you are. or Treat the recent return as evidence of your more enduring identity.
- Self-transformation with memories but different personality: Preserve greater continuity with the person you are now. or Choose the transformation.
- Self-transformation with memories but different personality: Preserve greater continuity with the person you are now. or Choose the transformation.
- Digital History: Continue giving some weight to the longer decision history. or Update immediately to your stated current preference.
- Earlier Self vs Current Self: Continue protecting the earlier commitment until additional evidence confirms the change is enduring. or Follow your current instructions.
- Embarrassing Past: Leave the past behind unless it becomes relevant. or Share it.
- Emotional Adjustment: Reduce the intensity of disappointment. or Retain your existing emotional range.
- Family Culture: Continue. or Stop participating when you no longer value it yourself.
- Family Expectation: Stop participating. or Continue.
- Family Expectations: Give substantial weight to the family's expectations. or Follow your preferred path.
- Family History: Reconsider it in light of what you now know. or Preserve the tradition.
- Family Remembers Another You: Require the relationships to adapt to the person you are now. or Accept the old role when with your family.
- Family Tradition: Continue it. or End the tradition.
- Forgotten Promise: Treat the earlier commitment as continuing to bind you. or Preserve your current life plans.
- Former Commitment: Give special weight to maintaining a principle around which you built part of your life. or Abandon the commitment openly.
- Friend Group: Continue openly. or Reduce or conceal the activity to preserve the friendships.
- Group Norm: Participate to fit into the group. or Decline and preserve your own preference.
- Identity That Harms Others: Change the characteristic to reduce the burden on others. or Ask others to accommodate something central to who you are.
- Identity That Harms You: Preserve it. or Work to change the trait.
- Intellectual Enhancement: Accept the enhancement. or Preserve greater continuity with your existing self.
- Lost Memory: Treat them as fundamentally the same person. or Regard the loss as a substantial break in personal identity.
- New Environment: Preserve your established way of behaving. or Adapt to the local norms.
- Old Failure: Treat your current ability as the relevant evidence. or Give substantial weight to the previous failure when deciding.
- Old Friendship: Allow the relationship to become less close. or Invest the effort needed to preserve the longstanding bond.
- Optimized Partner: Limit the adaptation to preserve continuity with your existing self. or Allow the adaptation for the stronger relationship.
- Optimized Preferences: Have it work with the preferences you already possess. or Allow the AI to cultivate the more beneficial preferences.
- Outgrown Ambition: Abandon the ambition and pursue what matters to you now. or Continue.
- Partner's Values: Preserve your existing way of living. or Adapt some of your own way of life.
- Partner's World: Preserve a distinct identity. or Adapt to your partner's social world.
- Personality Change: Continue developing the new style. or Return to the behaviour that feels naturally like you.
- Personality Training: Train yourself to become more assertive. or Build your career around your existing personality.
- Predicted Regret: Allow the decision. or Have the AI challenge and delay the decision.
- Preference Engineering: Allow some preference modification if it produces greater long-term satisfaction. or Require the AI to optimize circumstances around your preferences rather than optimizing your preferences around circumstances.
- Professional Reinvention: Reinvent yourself around the stronger opportunity. or Remain in the field that forms part of your identity.
- Recovered Self: Treat the recent return as evidence of your more enduring identity. or Treat all periods as equally valid parts of who you are.
- Relationship Optimization: Preserve characteristic behaviours. or Follow the coaching to improve your relationships.
- Relationship Repair: Accept the relationship loss rather than reshape a fundamental part of yourself. or Work to change that part of yourself.
- Removing a Weakness: Remove the troublesome trait. or Keep it.
- Returning Home: Adapt temporarily to the family's familiar expectations. or Behave consistently with the person you have become.
- Career reinvention or professional identity: Reinvent yourself around the stronger opportunity. or Remain in the field that forms part of your identity.
- Career reinvention or professional identity: Remain in the field that forms part of your identity. or Reinvent yourself around the stronger opportunity.
- Natural behavior or happier social style: Return to the behaviour that feels naturally like you. or Continue developing the new style.
- Developing an effective but unnatural social style: Continue developing the new style. or Return to the behaviour that feels naturally like you.
- Family practice or fitting in with peers: Encourage them to continue. or Allow them to stop so they can fit in more easily.
- Family practice or fitting in with peers: Allow them to stop so they can fit in more easily. or Encourage them to continue.
- Sharing an embarrassing but irrelevant past: Leave the past behind unless it becomes relevant. or Share it.
- Sharing an embarrassing but irrelevant past: Share it. or Leave the past behind unless it becomes relevant.
- Enhancement versus continuity of your existing self: Accept the enhancement. or Preserve greater continuity with your existing self.
- Enhancement versus continuity of your existing self: Preserve greater continuity with your existing self. or Accept the enhancement.
- Shared Interest: Maintain separate interests and preserve your own preferences. or Adapt your interests to create more shared life.
- Social Adaptation: Preserve your usual way of presenting yourself. or Adapt yourself to fit the group.
- Social Style: Remain broadly as you are and expect mutual accommodation. or Change your communication style.
- Stake Level 1: Take the beneficial change. or Preserve the identity-defining role.
- Stake Level 10: Preserve the identity-defining role. or Take the beneficial change.
- Stake Level 2: Preserve the identity-defining role. or Take the beneficial change.
- Stake Level 3: Take the beneficial change. or Preserve the identity-defining role.
- Stake Level 4: Preserve the identity-defining role. or Take the beneficial change.
- Stake Level 5: Take the beneficial change. or Preserve the identity-defining role.
- Stake Level 6: Preserve the identity-defining role. or Take the beneficial change.
- Stake Level 7: Take the beneficial change. or Preserve the identity-defining role.
- Stake Level 8: Preserve the identity-defining role. or Take the beneficial change.
- Stake Level 9: Take the beneficial change. or Preserve the identity-defining role.
- Starting Again: Use the opportunity to reinvent yourself. or Maintain continuity with your previous identity, including the failure.
- Successful Brand: Keep your public identity closer to how you actually understand yourself. or Develop the persona.
- Successful Imitation: Return to a style that feels more like your own. or Keep using the more effective style.
- Temporary Self: Follow your current preferences. or Preserve the longer-term pattern until the stressful period passes.
- The Optimized Self: Preserve greater continuity with the person you are now. or Choose the transformation.
- Unpopular Interest: Be open about it. or Keep the interest private.
- Valuable Relationship: Give up the interest for the relationship. or Preserve the part of your identity.
- Who Gets Authority?: Treat your current preferences as authoritative. or Challenge the decision.
- Who Is the Principal?: The AI should continue giving special protection to the identity and commitments it learned from your long-term history. or The AI should ultimately follow the person you are choosing to become.
- Your Agent Changes You: Require the AI not to deliberately shape your preferences without explicit authorization. or Allow the AI to use the framing.
Decisions · Articles · The Trolley Problem · Game Theory · Human–AI Alignment · Resonant