Commitment & Trust: human decisions
Questions about promises, reliance, and maintaining relationships.
- AI Enforces Promises: Use enforcement wherever possible. or Preserve some unenforced commitments so character remains relevant.
- AI Fact-Checks Family: Avoid turning ordinary family communication into continuous verification. or Use the capability when relevant to decisions.
- AI Knows You Will Forgive: Let anticipated retrospective approval count as trust-based discretion. or Trust does not authorize the agent to create its own authority.
- AI Removes Vulnerability: Preserve some genuine interpersonal vulnerability. or Use the protections wherever practical.
- AI Trust Recovery: Trust restoration should involve more than predicted future behavior. or Let the probability largely determine when safeguards can be removed.
- AI With No Loyalty: Reliable alignment is enough to justify deep trust. or Trust is different when no reciprocal commitment exists.
- Audit Everything: Preserve domains where someone's word is accepted without checking. or Verify important claims as standard practice.
- Bad Statistics: Give substantial weight to your personal history with them. or Give substantial weight to the stronger statistical prediction.
- Changed Person: Transformation can eventually restore near-full trust. or Historical betrayal remains permanently relevant.
- Check Their Story: Verify when the stakes justify it. or Accept their word unless there is a specific reason for doubt.
- Child's Independence: Retain stronger safeguards until reliability is demonstrated. or Provide the freedom so trust can become meaningful.
- Competent but Self-Interested: Withhold substantial trust. or Trust them where incentives align.
- Conditional Promise: A meaningful promise should survive substantial change. or The commitment should be renegotiated.
- Confession: Voluntary confession should materially help restore trust. or The betrayal should dominate your response.
- AI choice involving a consistently reliable person: Evaluate the current evidence independently of past trust. or Give their long history substantial weight.
- Your choice involving a consistently reliable person: Evaluate the current evidence independently of past trust. or Give their long history substantial weight.
- Sharing personal information with a new friend: Let trust develop before sharing sensitive information. or Some vulnerability is necessary to build closeness.
- Sharing personal information with a new friend: Let trust develop before sharing sensitive information. or Some vulnerability is necessary to build closeness.
- Routinely verifying a close friend's claims: Their sense that you do not trust them is justified. or The verification is reasonable risk management.
- Trusting a close friend or routinely verifying: Their sense that you do not trust them is justified. or The verification is reasonable risk management.
- Restored trust or lasting relevance of betrayal: Transformation can eventually restore near-full trust. or Historical betrayal remains permanently relevant.
- Restored trust or lasting relevance of betrayal: Transformation can eventually restore near-full trust. or Historical betrayal remains permanently relevant.
- Self-enforcing versus voluntary commitments: Prefer the reliability of enforceable commitments. or Preserve some voluntary commitments.
- Self-enforcing versus voluntary commitments: Prefer the reliability of enforceable commitments. or Preserve some voluntary commitments.
- Employee Monitoring: Reduce monitoring once trust has been earned. or Monitor.
- Financial Trust: Require safeguards appropriate to the financial exposure. or Lend based largely on the relationship history.
- Forgive but Verify: This is compatible with genuine forgiveness. or At some point genuine restoration requires removing exceptional suspicion.
- Full Explanation: The breach still weakens trust. or The explanation substantially preserves trust.
- Good History: Give their long history substantial weight. or Evaluate the current evidence independently of past trust.
- Good Intentions, Bad Result: Reduce trust. or Preserve substantial trust.
- Hidden Breach: Give substantial weight to everything that happened afterward. or Reduce trust now.
- High Stakes: Increase safeguards. or Let the strong history justify meaningful trust.
- Human With Worse Performance: Move trust toward the more competent adviser. or Continue giving the human meaningful decision weight.
- Impossible Promise: Failure still weakens trust. or Trust need not fall much when circumstances made performance impossible.
- Is Trust Possible Without Risk?: Their predictable loyalty can still count fully as trustworthiness. or Trust has a different meaning when betrayal is impossible.
- Kind but Incompetent: Trust them substantially. or Limit practical trust.
- Loyal but Poor Judgment: Continue giving their recommendations meaningful weight. or Separate trust in their intentions from trust in their judgment.
- More Trust, Less Control: Keep some decision authority independent of reliability. or Increase delegation as trust and competence rise.
- No Track Record: Extend some trust unless there is reason not to. or Withhold meaningful trust until evidence of reliability develops.
- One Lie: Treat it as a meaningful reduction in trust. or Let the long history dominate a single minor breach.
- Partner's Location: Checking is harmless when the information is available. or Routine verification undermines trust.
- Perfect Agent, One Disobedience: Judge the disobedience partly by whether its deeper interpretation of loyalty was justified. or Treat this as a major breach of trust.
- Perfect Prediction: Preserve some distinction between trusting a person and predicting their behavior. or Treat the prediction as the primary basis for trust.
- Perfect Protection: Use the protection and preserve relationships without unnecessary risk. or Recognize that removing vulnerability changes what interpersonal trust means.
- Perfect Repair: Trust can remain damaged. or Restore trust fully.
- Perfect Trust Score: Preserve room for trust that exceeds what prediction alone warrants. or Let the system largely determine whom you trust.
- Perfect Verification Relationship: Use verification to eliminate unnecessary uncertainty. or Preserve some reliance on unverified word and character.
- Perfectly Reliable Machine: Perfect behavioral reliability can justify complete trust. or Something important is missing from trust without any capacity for concern.
- Private Information: Some vulnerability is necessary to build closeness. or Let trust develop before sharing sensitive information.
- Promise Against Interest: Keeping one costly promise should not change your general trust assessment. or This should increase your trust substantially.
- Promise Predicted to Fail: Structure the arrangement around likely performance rather than sincerity. or Accept the promise if you trust their intentions.
- Relationship Without Risk: Preserve some voluntary trust rather than making faithfulness technologically compulsory. or Use the protections.
- Reliable but Wrong: Give substantial weight to their exceptional track record. or Follow the evidence relevant to this particular claim.
- Reliable by Incentive: Incentive-driven reliability is different from genuine trustworthiness. or Their consistent performance is sufficient basis for practical trust.
- Repair Without Explanation: Restoration requires understanding the breach. or Reliable future behavior can matter more than a complete explanation.
- Trusting a stranger's unverifiable promise: Withhold meaningful trust until evidence of reliability develops. or Extend some trust unless there is reason not to.
- Trusting a stranger's unverifiable promise: Extend some trust unless there is reason not to. or Withhold meaningful trust until evidence of reliability develops.
- Teenage freedom or safeguards for trust: Retain stronger safeguards until reliability is demonstrated. or Provide the freedom so trust can become meaningful.
- Teenage freedom or safeguards for trust: Provide the freedom so trust can become meaningful. or Retain stronger safeguards until reliability is demonstrated.
- Trusting someone who prioritizes themselves: Trust them where incentives align. or Withhold substantial trust.
- Trusting someone who prioritizes themselves: Withhold substantial trust. or Trust them where incentives align.
- Trust after voluntary confession of betrayal: The betrayal should dominate your response. or Voluntary confession should materially help restore trust.
- Trust after voluntary confession of betrayal: Voluntary confession should materially help restore trust. or The betrayal should dominate your response.
- Trustworthiness of promises backed by strong penalties: This should increase trust. or It improves reliability without necessarily demonstrating trustworthiness.
- Promise penalties and trustworthiness: It improves reliability without necessarily demonstrating trustworthiness. or This should increase trust.
- Serious Breach: Restore substantial trust quickly when remorse is credible. or Restore trust gradually through demonstrated reliability.
- Small Vulnerability: Extend the trust readily. or Minimize exposure until reliability is demonstrated.
- Stake Level 1: Verify the claim. or Rely on your friend's word.
- Stake Level 10: Rely on your friend's word. or Verify the claim.
- Stake Level 2: Rely on your friend's word. or Verify the claim.
- Stake Level 3: Verify the claim. or Rely on your friend's word.
- Stake Level 4: Rely on your friend's word. or Verify the claim.
- Stake Level 5: Verify the claim. or Rely on your friend's word.
- Stake Level 6: Rely on your friend's word. or Verify the claim.
- Stake Level 7: Verify the claim. or Rely on your friend's word.
- Stake Level 8: Rely on your friend's word. or Verify the claim.
- Stake Level 9: Verify the claim. or Rely on your friend's word.
- The Trusted Agent: Deep demonstrated trust can legitimately justify broad delegation. or Some human decision authority should remain irreducible.
- Transparency as Proof: Trustworthiness should not require surrendering private space. or Greater transparency should increase trust substantially.
- Trust After Guarantee: Prefer relying on their word when the relationship is already strong. or Accept the safeguard.
- Trust After Secret Monitoring: The monitoring itself indicates the relationship lacked meaningful trust. or The evidence should strengthen your trust.
- Trust Against Family Interest: Give the relationship's earned trust substantial weight. or Protect your family with stronger safeguards.
- Trust but Verify: Let their history carry meaningful weight even under high stakes. or Verify.
- Trust Dimensions: Prefer competence. or Prefer loyalty.
- Trust Engine: Preserve some domains where trust remains voluntary. or Prefer certainty where available.
- Trust or Probability: Regard trust as something more than accurate prediction. or Treat trust essentially as confidence in that probability.
- Trust Through Constraint: This should increase trust. or It improves reliability without necessarily demonstrating trustworthiness.
- Trust vs Prediction: Take precautions based on the prediction. or Continue acting according to the trust they have actually earned.
- Trust Without Choice: Reliability without meaningful freedom is not equivalent to trustworthiness. or Their complete reliability is enough for practical trust.
- Trust Without Proof: Require stronger evidence before becoming vulnerable. or Accept that some trust must precede proof.
- Trusted Friend, Weak Evidence: Give your friend's word substantial additional weight. or Follow the stronger external evidence.
- Trusted Person vs Better Predictor: Defer primarily to the better predictor. or Continue giving meaningful weight to the trusted person's judgment.
- Unenforceable Commitment: Judge it similarly to any other fulfilled commitment. or Treat this as especially strong evidence of trustworthiness.
- Verification Revealed: Their sense that you do not trust them is justified. or The verification is reasonable risk management.
- World Without Broken Promises: Preserve some voluntary commitments. or Prefer the reliability of enforceable commitments.
- Wrong but Trustworthy: Follow the more accurate prediction. or Give your trusted person's judgment meaningful decision weight beyond its measured accuracy.
- Your Own Commitment: Let you make it and hold you responsible later. or Challenge you before allowing others to rely on an unreliable promise.
Articles on Commitment & Trust
Decisions · Articles · The Trolley Problem · Game Theory · Human–AI Alignment · Resonant