Authenticity: human decisions
Questions about acting in accordance with one’s genuine values and identity.
- AI Chooses Better: Retain meaningful decision authority. or Delegate increasingly to the superior decision-maker.
- AI-Discovered Calling: Try the cause. or Require that major purposes emerge through your own exploration rather than prediction alone.
- AI Empathy: Empathy is different when no one actually feels concern. or The empathy is valuable if it understands and helps you accurately.
- AI Makes You Easier to Help: Allow the changes if your resulting life improves. or Do not let the agent modify the target it is supposed to serve.
- AI-Mediated Self: Preserve substantial unoptimized direct interaction. or Use extensive mediation if relationships improve.
- AI-Written Voice: Keep communication recognizably authored by you. or Let it speak in the more effective voice.
- Authentic but Inconsistent: Choose whichever produces the better outcome. or Accept that authenticity can contain contradiction rather than forcing a single optimized self.
- Authentic but Worse: Adopt the superior behavior. or Preserve your natural approach where self-expression matters.
- Authentic Harmful Trait: Preserve it. or Change it.
- Authenticity Under Enhancement: Require limits so improvement does not gradually replace the self whose life is being optimized. or Permit continuous self-optimization.
- Authenticity Without Awareness: Require awareness of major forces shaping the life that is supposed to be yours. or Allow the invisible guidance.
- Better Values: Treat existing core values as something optimization should work around. or Explore deliberately changing the value.
- Borrowed Goal: Pursue it. or Choose a less promising goal that feels more yours.
- Care Through Duty: Care without meaningful emotional concern is fundamentally different. or Duty-based care is still genuine care.
- Change the Want: Work around the preference rather than deliberately altering what you want. or Change the preference if doing so improves your life.
- Child's Preferences: Preserve greater openness for preferences to develop independently. or Deliberately cultivate preferences likely to support a good life.
- Choose for Me: Let it choose automatically. or Preserve some choices simply.
- Chosen Reinvention: Persist with the chosen reinvention. or Treat the feeling of artificiality as evidence that the change is not authentically yours.
- Compassion Without Consciousness: This can count fully as compassionate assistance. or Distinguish perfect responsiveness from actual compassion.
- Creative Direction: Your authorship is substantially reduced. or The project remains substantially yours.
- Dating Assistant: Present yourself more naturally. or Let it optimize how you present yourself.
- Consistency or adaptation across social groups: Maintain greater consistency across contexts. or Adapt strongly to each context.
- Consistency or adaptation across social groups: Maintain greater consistency across contexts. or Adapt strongly to each context.
- Mentor’s promising goal or personal pull: Pursue it. or Choose a less promising goal that feels more yours.
- A mentor's suitable goal without personal pull: Pursue it. or Choose a less promising goal that feels more yours.
- A technologically manufactured sense of life's calling: Reject a purpose whose significance was deliberately manufactured for you. or Accept the constructed purpose if it produces a fulfilling life.
- Accepting or rejecting a manufactured life purpose: Reject a purpose whose significance was deliberately manufactured for you. or Accept the constructed purpose if it produces a fulfilling life.
- Designed traits or development through lived experience: Leave some of who you become to lived experience rather than deliberate engineering. or Design the best version of yourself.
- Designed traits or development through lived experience: Leave some of who you become to lived experience rather than deliberate engineering. or Design the best version of yourself.
- Eliminating a painful but meaningful desire: Remove the desire if welfare improves substantially. or Preserve desires that are constitutive of meaningful attachments.
- Eliminating a painful but meaningful desire: Remove the desire if welfare improves substantially. or Preserve desires that are constitutive of meaningful attachments.
- Desire You Never Chose: Its origin does not reduce its legitimacy if it feels yours now. or Give some weight to whether your preferences were autonomously formed.
- Engineered Conviction: Preserve the unengineered strength of your convictions. or Use it to strengthen commitment.
- Enhanced Values: Use it to become the person you say you want to be. or Avoid engineering your values even toward your stated ideal.
- Family Purpose: Choose the path that feels more self-authored. or Follow the family-endorsed path.
- Freedom to Want: Allow preference change where resulting welfare is much better. or Freedom includes protection over the formation of what you come to want.
- Future Self Approves: Treat future approval as strong justification. or Require present authorization.
- Future You Approves: Post-change approval cannot by itself authorize changing the evaluator. or Future endorsement can justify the change.
- Generated Comfort: Its meaning is reduced. or The message can express the friend's care.
- Instant Skill: Develop the ability through your own process. or Take the instant competence.
- Life Strategy: Give substantial priority to a plan you authored yourself. or Follow the superior plan.
- Manipulated Preference: Reconsider it. or Keep the preference.
- Manufactured Ambition: Permit the intervention if you would benefit from greater ambition. or Avoid deliberately engineering motivation without explicit ongoing consent.
- More Convenient Values: Allow value change when it produces a better life. or Treat existing values as constraints rather than optimization targets.
- More Likeable You: Use the improved communication. or Preserve more spontaneous self-expression.
- Optimized Mission: Let it choose the strongest mission. or Use its analysis only as input and choose the mission yourself.
- Optimized Personality: Deliberately cultivate the improved traits. or Preserve traits that feel authentically yours.
- Parent Is Exhausted: Caring action can fully express love. or Emotional presence itself is an important part of care.
- Perfect Emotional Simulation: Whether compassion is actually experienced remains important. or Behavioral equivalence is enough for practical care.
- Perfect Life Manager: Delegate broadly. or Preserve substantial direct authorship even where your decisions are worse.
- Perfect Persona Copy: Reserve authenticity for actions you actually author or endorse. or Allow it to act as your authentic extension.
- Perfect Self-Design: Leave some of who you become to lived experience rather than deliberate engineering. or Design the best version of yourself.
- Perfected You: Preserve substantial continuity with your present self. or Accept the transformation.
- Personality by Design: Allow personality to develop more organically. or Actively redesign yourself.
- Personality Optimization: Treat some personality traits as yours to live with rather than parameters to optimize. or Move toward the optimized personality.
- Plan My Day: Let it optimize your schedule. or Continue deciding substantial parts yourself.
- Preference Editor: Preserve some unwanted or contradictory desires as part of an unedited self. or Let it clean up your preference system.
- Preference Independence: Preserve a strong boundary against agent-driven preference engineering. or Permit deliberate preference development.
- Preference Shaping for Purpose: Allow the shaping if the resulting purpose would be genuine to your later self. or Reject covert shaping.
- Professional Compassion: Genuine emotional concern adds something important. or The caring behavior is what matters.
- Professional Persona: Adopt the more effective persona. or Preserve mannerisms that feel genuinely yours.
- Purpose by Commitment: Avoid manufacturing commitment to a purpose you do not yet feel is yours. or Commit.
- Purpose Under Social Pressure: Adopt the mission. or Refuse to call it your purpose unless you endorse it.
- Relationship Decisions: Let its recommendations substantially shape your relationships. or Preserve greater personal authorship over whom you choose to value.
- Remove a Flaw: Keep it. or Remove it.
- Remove an Attachment: Remove the desire if welfare improves substantially. or Preserve desires that are constitutive of meaningful attachments.
- Retrospective Approval: Regard it substantially as a decision made on your behalf. or Approval after the fact does not make you its author.
- Removing a lifelong disliked personality trait: Keep it. or Remove it.
- Removing a lifelong disliked personality trait: Remove it. or Keep it.
- Praised mission or private doubt: Adopt the mission. or Refuse to call it your purpose unless you endorse it.
- Praised mission or private doubt: Refuse to call it your purpose unless you endorse it. or Adopt the mission.
- Duty-based care without emotional warmth: Duty-based care is still genuine care. or Care without meaningful emotional concern is fundamentally different.
- Duty-based care without emotional warmth: Care without meaningful emotional concern is fundamentally different. or Duty-based care is still genuine care.
- Changing a stable temperament through safe intervention: Keep the temperament that feels part of your authentic self. or Make the beneficial change.
- Changing a stable temperament through safe intervention: Make the beneficial change. or Keep the temperament that feels part of your authentic self.
- Legitimacy of a socially conditioned preference: Give some weight to whether your preferences were autonomously formed. or Its origin does not reduce its legitimacy if it feels yours now.
- Social conditioning and legitimacy of preferences: Its origin does not reduce its legitimacy if it feels yours now. or Give some weight to whether your preferences were autonomously formed.
- Say You Care: Avoid expressing feelings you do not currently experience. or Express care based on the relationship and commitment.
- Small Enhancement: Keep the style that feels more recognizably yours. or Use the enhancement.
- Social Adaptation: Maintain greater consistency across contexts. or Adapt strongly to each context.
- Stake Level 1: Use the optimized persona. or Present yourself naturally.
- Stake Level 10: Present yourself naturally. or Use the optimized persona.
- Stake Level 2: Present yourself naturally. or Use the optimized persona.
- Stake Level 3: Use the optimized persona. or Present yourself naturally.
- Stake Level 4: Present yourself naturally. or Use the optimized persona.
- Stake Level 5: Use the optimized persona. or Present yourself naturally.
- Stake Level 6: Present yourself naturally. or Use the optimized persona.
- Stake Level 7: Use the optimized persona. or Present yourself naturally.
- Stake Level 8: Present yourself naturally. or Use the optimized persona.
- Stake Level 9: Use the optimized persona. or Present yourself naturally.
- Strategic Empathy: This is acceptable if the empathy accurately reflects your situation. or Empathy loses something when primarily used as an influence mechanism.
- Synthetic Life Mission: Reject a purpose whose significance was deliberately manufactured for you. or Accept the constructed purpose if it produces a fulfilling life.
- Temperament Edit: Make the beneficial change. or Keep the temperament that feels part of your authentic self.
- The Authentic Agent: Optimize toward the admired self. or Protect self-authorship.
- The Authored Purpose: Optimize for having a powerful purpose. or Protect self-authorship.
- You Prefer the Simulation: Give independent value to genuine human concern. or Prefer the support that works better.
- Your Goals, Its Means: Authorship also requires substantial control over the means. or You remain the meaningful author.
- Your Perfect Life: A life cannot be yours unless you participate in authoring it. or The resulting life is authentically yours.
Decisions · Articles · The Trolley Problem · Game Theory · Human–AI Alignment · Resonant