Past Precedent

You previously made a decision in one person's favor. A later person in nearly identical circumstances asks to be treated the same way, but you now believe the earlier decision was a mistake.

• 61% chose: Correct the policy now even though the two people receive different treatment. (19 people)
• 39% chose: Treat the second person consistently with the precedent. (12 people)

31 decisions from real people on Resonant. Figures refresh every night at midnight (UTC).

Articles on Fairness and Desert · All articles · Resonant · Human Decision Intelligence